Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Energy:the big picture


This is a sad hoax, for industrial man no longer eats potatoes made from solar energy; now he eats potatoes partly made of oil. (Howard T Odum)

There are only three primary energy sources on earth, solar energy, the gravitation of the sun and the moon and the geothermal energy. Of these, solar energy is completely dominating. These primary forms are the origin of all the secondary forms; biomass (from photosynthesis); circulation of water (which allows us to extract hydro-electricity); the wind; tidal flows and geological processes (volcano eruption, erosion, earthquakes etc.) The primary and secondary energy sources that formed the oil, photosynthesis, geological movements and geothermal energy are all diluted and difficult to use. But they have had a very long time to create a very concentrated product, which can be extracted for a low cost and be the basis for other energy carriers, such as electricity and petrol. It is the great “work” of the bio-geosphere that has created the energy intensity of oil compared to the original biomass.

Energy has been central for the dramatic increase of productivity of human labour. The tremendously improved, and thereby cheaper, transport that resulting from cheap oil is a key driver in the globalization of our economy and of our life. The economic importance, and the implications, of this largely surpass the importance of the World Trade Organization (WTO) and the EU and other free trade agreements, or possibly one could even say that they are a result of energy use[1]. Despite us living in an industrial society, or as some claim, an information society, agriculture is still very important and the interaction between energy and agriculture has major implications as oil reserves dwindle. It works both ways. It is largely through the use of external energy that labour productivity in farming has increased. On the other hand, historically and ecologically, agriculture was supposed to deliver more energy than it consumed. That was the whole point of farming in the first place. But agriculture of today, and even worse our food system at large, is a huge net consumer of energy. At the same time, expectations are that we will produce more biomass and energy from farming. Those are the reasons for why this chapter discuss the energy and agriculture nexus thoroughly.

Energy costs represent some 3 percent of GDP. This fact can lure us into believing that energy is not so important for our economy. But nothing could be more wrong. Water costs are almost negligible and still most of our economy would collapse if there was no water, well all of it would collapse. If the 3 percent energy costs are taken away, most of the other 97 percent will vanish. Cheap energy, mainly in the form of fossil fuel, is the fuel of our whole economy, all things would grind to halt, like a car without petrol without it. This is also realised by many, even if most politicians try to do a balancing act of overplaying our ability to find other solutions and underplaying our extreme dependency of fossil fuel. It is like we found an enormous bag of candy that someone left, and we just eat and eat. How important energy is, is also reflected in the substantial subsidies that are directed to fossils fuel, which are calculated by IEA to US$ 650 billion in 2008 (UNEP 2011)

Energy use and supply

Since the first oil crisis in the mid 1970s, the energy consumption per capita in high income countries has stagnated. Transport energy is an exception and has almost doubled in the high income countries. Globally, the supply of energy has doubled in the same period. The transportation sector accounts for over a quarter of total world energy use, and the proportion has increased since 1973. Cars, trucks and air transport take most of the transport energy; in the EU, road transport represents 82% and air transport represent 14% of the transport energy. Transport of people both for work and for leisure increase dramatically as people become wealthier. A flight from England to Mallorca was a big thing, and very costly in the 1960s, now it is almost like catching a bus, and would be a lot more so if it weren’t for all the security measures. Unless there is a major shift away from current patterns of energy use, world transportation energy use is expected to grow at 2% per year, with energy use 80% above 2002 levels by 2030 (UNEP 2009, IEA 2009, EU 2010).

With increasing awareness about problem with climate and political and economic uncertainties about oil and gas supplies there is a renewed interest in bio-energy and renewable fuels. It should be noted that the supply of energy from biomass is double the supply of energy from nuclear power and that in developing countries biomass represents a much higher proportion than in the high-income countries. Still fossil fuel represents 80 percent of all supplied energy as can be seen from the graph below.

The energy input per GDP unit is decreasing in most countries and, perhaps surprising, most in China.

The poorest people have very limited access to energy; it is largely limited to firewood that is collected by household members, often women and children, manure or other combustible waste products[2]. Approximately 2.6 billion people live with these as their main energy source (UNIDO 2008). There is a strict energy hierarchy for household energy in the sense that with increasing income people move from wood to coal (charcoal or mineral coal), kerosene, PNG and finally electricity. Around 1.6 billion people have no access to electricity. Apart from the comfort and health advantages of electrical light compared to kerosene or firewood, electrification can lead to substantial economic development. In the Philippines, it is estimated that electrification of the rural areas would have a value of between 81 and 150 dollars per household per year. More than any other factor, access to energy can explain the difference in productivity between poor and rich.


[1] The origin of the EU is actually as a “Coal and steel union”.

[2] In the 1990s, I met farmers in China who used cotton straw as their source of energy for cooking.


The text is an extract from Garden Earth, my forthcoming book

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Towards a society of services or servants?

Most people would do their cleaning themselves if they had to pay the cleaning lady the same salary as their own, it is as simple as that.

It is said that we are moving towards a society of services. There is some truth in this, even if manufacturing still plays a bigger role than many believe. Globally manufacturing is actually not shrinking, even if it goes down in high-income countries. On the global level, the striking change is from agriculture to services. Historically there was a transformation from agriculture to industry to services but in some countries, notably in Sub-Saharan Africa, there is no such transition; people move out from the agriculture sector directly to the service sector. When we look at the proportion of people employed in different sectors, and not the absolute number of people, we forget that the number of people working in e.g. farming is very high and in most parts of the world actually rather stable. Between 1970 and 2000 the number of people engaged in the farm sector in Latin America was more or less constant (Ploeg 2009). Perhaps even more surprising for many is that despite the rapid pace of urbanization the number of people in rural areas and the number of farms are increasing and not decreasing (although this will change quite soon and the number of farmers certainly is on a rapid decrease in high-income countries).

Table 19: World employment by sector 1998-2008

Agriculture (%)

Industry (%)

Service (%)

1998

2008

1998

2008

1998

2008

World

41.6

34.5

20

21.6

38.4

43.8

High-Income countries

5.8

3.7

28.0

24.9

66.2

71.4

Source: KILM 2010

We can see more detail from the US employment data, where retail trade is a bigger employer than manufacturing, however in terms of economic output it only “produce” one third as much value. Professional and business service is a growth sector as well as health care. 9.6 million were employed in food services (restaurants, bars, catering) and 1.5 million in food manufacturing, 15.3 million in retail, compared to just above 2 million in the agriculture sector (Bartsch 2009)

The statistics mask that earlier a lot of the services, e.g. health care and personal care was performed outside of the formal labour market, mainly in the families. Also, manufacturing has outsourced a lot of functions which means that was earlier counted as “manufacturing” is today called services. The growing service sector has four distinct segments. One is the professional services oriented to the business and industries, it can be auditing, engineering, back office functions of many kinds. In the statistics, these same jobs if they are performed in-house the factory would be qualified as a manufacturing job. These kinds of services are generally speaking well paid. Second, we have the whole apparatus of wholesale, transport and retail, together representing 17-18 percent of the work force in the USA. Some of that is also oriented to manufacturing, but most of it is for the consumer market. There is a hospitality industry dominated by restaurants, bars and drinking places with almost ten percent of the work force. This sector is where we find a lot of low-paid low skilled work. Third, we have the police, health care and education, things that in most countries are performed by the public sector. Often these jobs are quite badly paid, but have better employment conditions than the retail or restaurants. Fourth, there is the pure personal service sector, cleaning, massage, shoe-shining etc. things that historically were done by servants. Here conditions are often bad, in some countries a lot of it is done by migrant workers, legal or illegal. Those who predict that there will be a lot of growth in that sector also predicts that we will continue to have big differences in income because it is basically differences in income that drives and make possible most of these kinds of services.


Bartlett: ”The greatest shortcoming of our human race is our inability to understand the exponential function”

In times of constant calls for more growth, this video gives a healthy perspective.

”The greatest shortcoming of our human race is our inability to understand the exponential function”



It can be applied to economic growth, population, profits and whatever you like.
The professor has also said :
"'Smart growth' destroys the environment. 'Dumb growth' destroys the environment. The only difference is that 'smart growth' does it with good taste. It's like booking passage on the Titanic. Whether you go first-class or steerage, the result is the same."

Monday, March 21, 2011

From Fire to oil

To look at the history of humanity through an energy lens is as interesting as looking at it through an economic, a political or a socio-biological lens. We can describe the whole history of human kind as the consecutive conquest of new forms of energy sources and technologies that made the usage of them efficient and effective. The arrowhead and the dagger of stone made it possible for us to hunt large game, to use the energy of our arms better. The fire let us get energy out of wood which made metallurgy and pottery possible as well as settlement in colder areas. Farming meant taming the photosynthesis (a form of solar energy) to meet human needs. Animals were domesticated not only for food but also for transport and power in agriculture. The use of wind for sailing dramatically extended our reach, new areas could be settled and trade allowed settlement in places which could not be settled before. For each new form of energy, there is a technological process to control and target the energy form in a better way. We increase the heat of fire with bellows; for the horses, we develop harness, wagons, saddles, reigns, spurs and bridles, each one of them essential to “harness” the energy. Technology can with this perspective largely be seen as a process to “direct” energy.

In the infancy of industrialization, we learned how to convert water and wind power to mechanical power, and thereafter we learned to use fossil fuels. For each of these steps, humans have taken bigger proportions of the planets energy sources into their use. And for each step the population and the consumption level has jumped. Also, our societal structures can be interpreted in the perspective of energy. The agrarian revolution led to a society where some, a few rulers, could appropriate the energy of the masses for their own purposes, through slavery, serfdom or forced labour. Also within the family, women have provided their human energy for the service of men to some extent. With more and cheaper external energy sources, the interest in forced labour is substantially reduced and it prevails mainly in sectors where energy and mechanization doesn’t play much role, i.e. in service occupations, including prostitution. Another way of looking at the same development is ”the landed gentry who owned large solar-collecting estates were replaced at the top of the financial and social ladder by the new industrialists who directed new production systems using the more concentrated energies of coal and then oil”(Hall and Klitgaard 2006).

For more details on the steps in the transformation from fire to oil, read this posting

Use a stopper - save a hoppper!


I am not sure that humor can save the world, but it certainly helps.

The Center for Biological Diversity distributed 350,000 free Endangered Species Condoms in all 50 states — as well as Canada, Puerto Rico, and Mexico — to highlight how unsustainable human population growth is driving species extinct at a cataclysmic rate. Good initiative, and also good that it sees poupulation growht as a problem also in rich countries. After all an American is likely to waste a lot more resources than an Indian or a Sudanese. They write:
  • The United States has by far the highest fertility rate of any developed nation, with a population that has already surpassed 300 million and could reach 450 million by 2050.
  • The combination of rapid population growth and extremely high levels of consumption makes the United States a key factor in the overpopulation equation.

Sunday, March 20, 2011

Whose nature?

When we discuss environmental destruction. we should keep in mind that exploitation of nature is also a question of whose nature. Different groups are affected by destruction of nature in different ways, and normally nature of the weaker is destroyed while the nature of the rich is preserved. This leads some to believe that the rich "care more" for the environment or that it is first when there is a certain wealth that humans "can afford" to care about nature, but this mixes up cause and effect to a large extent. The rich can exploit the nature of the poor and even export their waste to the poor, while the poor has no other option than exploitation of nature, be it in the form or their nature resources or in the form of their own labour. There are more "stuff" moving to the rich from the poor than the other way around; many dirty industries have moved to poor countries. To some extent the whole trick of modern civilization is about exploitation of nature; exploitation of historical production, of which fossil fuel is the primary example; exploitation of the future nature, by dumping waste. But it is also the history of a few people exploiting many other people. The fight for saving the environment and for a more just world are therefore intrinsically linked, it is basically the same fight.

Saturday, March 19, 2011

Which weather do you want to pay for?

It was always a human dream to control weather. Rain dances, sacrifices, prayers and other rituals have been used to call rain, stop rain, and protect crops from frost or floods. And we know today that we can influence the weather. Cutting down forests, especially in the tropics influence the climate so that was once a lush forest can become a try steppe; draining of field and wetlands lead to floods. And in the very big scale, global warming shows that we can even influence the global climate. Unfortunately, not in the direction we wanted perhaps, but still. And now the so called ‘international community' will have to agree which climate we should have. Should it be five degrees warmer or can we halt it on two degrees. Can the Canadians get five degrees warmer, while temperature is reduced in the tropics?

This kind of “production” is a growth market. Instead of seeing measures against global warming as costs, we can see it as production in the same way as parks, golf course and other things we make for our pleasure. One sees, already, how the corporate sector wants to ‘privatise’ this service; how the GDP can increase substantially. By economic incentives, we can not only solve a problem, but also turn the problem to a fantastic business opportunity, and new virgin market, more growth. The more far-sighted parts of the private sector has realised that there is huge opportunities in things like cap and trade; it takes away the right to collect pollution taxes from the government and place it in the hands of the companies. But one can also apply a completely contrary perspective, that we now start the process of final privatization of all resources on the planet. A privatization without parallel since the privatization of land; a process where markets take over all relations we have with nature.

Climate change has triggered ideas for large scale engineering of global systems. Large-scale ‘technological fixes’ fall into two categories. Carbon dioxide removal (CDR) techniques are designed to extract CO2 from the atmosphere. Solar radiation management (SRM) techniques are intended to reflect a portion of the sun’s light back into space. CDR is based on biological, chemical or geological carbon sequestration. SRM is based on natural effects observed in the atmosphere following volcanic eruptions. A proposal for ‘sunshade’ geo-engineering consists of the installation of space-based sun shields, or reflective mirrors, to deflect a proportion of incoming solar radiation before it reaches the atmosphere. Sunlight deflectors would be placed in near-Earth orbits or near the Lagrange point, about 1.5 million kilometres above the planet, where the gravitational pull of Earth and the sun are equal. An array of sunshades in this position would pose less threat to orbiting satellites than would near-Earth objects (UNEP 2010b, the Economist 2010b). If anything, these proposals underline the severity of the situation as well as how little we really know. They also give new perspectives on power. As Andre Matthews, an anthropologist at the University of California puts it, it is not just a matter of constructing a switch, it is a matter of constructing a hand you trust to flip it (the Economist 2010b).

We should also realise how little we understand and realise that the risks of such global large scale engineering are huge and totally unpredictable. Still, it is already a fact that we change many of the planet's systems enormously, but in the same way as most of these changes are a result of many small things (the car you drive, the meat you eat etc), also the solutions are to be found there rather than in macro engineering.
(extract from Garden Earth)

more posts on climate:

Guilt free?

"He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her."Jesus said according to the Bible. But there was no one there who was without sin (well apart from the man himself).

And now we can indulge coffee without guilt, from Guilt Free Drinks.



Somewhere, I get a bad aftertaste from this. It is partly because I find it weird marketing a product on being free from guilt. And perhaps even more, that it is such a simplistic thing to believe that just by buying a particular product you are "doing good", which is what they want to convey. And perhaps I am also a bit irritated about overstating the effect of a certain action. Too many companies use "save the world by buying my stuff" slogans, while in most cases you save the world better by buying nothing..

Addendum: I got a comment from the company, see below. I am sure they want to do good and that their product, organic and fairtrade most likely is a better product than coffee without those certifications. I haven't had the opportunity to taste the coffee myself. My post goes a bit further in discussion though.

This triple certification, organic, fair trade and carbon neutral is demonstrating a strong trend of "added value". And also that is all fine and good - but the coffee growers still only get a tiny fraction of the price of that coffee. In the end "added value" is exactly about moving things further away from the raw materials, in reality or just in perception, which then can motivate a higher price. But in many cases "added value" is actually a worse product than before the value was added (I don't claim that is the case with coffee though. Not roasted coffee, directly from the tree doesn't make such an interesting drink...)

Friday, March 18, 2011

Food is not a commodity like any other

Sin maíz, no hay país they say in Mexico, without maize there is no country. One of many expressions that underline the importance of food, not only for survival, but for our culture and for political stability. We know that lack of food can trigger political upheaval and perhaps revolution.

Sometimes, I am more surprised by the opposite, however. How come that the hungry sit and beg instead of just crashing into the shops and plunder, or trying to mug me? I guess it is a combination of the repressive society, culture and also that people that are poor and hungry, also are very tired and disillusioned. To rob or loot requires some strength and initiative, but most people starving are so tired. Honestly, can you say that it would be immoral for the person that is starving to steal a banana to eat? Would you also say that it is immoral for her to steal to giver her child to eat? I certainly could never condemn that.

If you want to read more about hunger, its causes and how to reduce it, I can recommend
Food enough, Land enough?
About hunger, agriculture, trade and global solidarity
by Peter Einarsson, published by Forum Syd, the Swedish Church and Swedish Cooperative center. The report ends with six rules of the thumb about food security.
1. The food supply will not take care of itself.
2. Food is not a commodity like any other..
3. Hunger is not a developing country problem..
4. The environmental food crisis is for real.
5. Technology is not the problem.
6. Globalize solidarity..

US$ 6.6 trillion: the bill noone pays

US$ 6.6 trillion are the estimated annual environmental costs from global
human activity equating to 11% of global GDP in 2008.
US$ 2.15 trillion is the cost of environmental damage caused by the world’s
3,000 largest publicly-listed companies in 200
according to a recent report

the beauty is that nobody pays the bill...or our grandchildren pay the bill.

Most of these polluters are supported by governments, according to my most popular blog post ever: The Polluter Gets Paid principle.

Thursday, March 17, 2011

250 billion energy slaves

Swedish peasant (yours truly some thirty years ago) weeding his veggies with primitive tool

One can contrast the energy content in humans with the external energy sources we have conquered, to give us an idea how important the development of external energy sources are. Let us do a back-of-the-envelope-calculation[1]. A human needs around 2,500 calories per day (2,9kWh[2]). We use around 80 percent of that just to stay awake, think, eat, sleep, breath etc. So a bit less than 600 Wh is perhaps for work. Hard working people could perhaps develop 800 Wh, but they will also eat more. On a yearly basis the average person consume around a million calories, which correspond to 1.16 MWh. The average American uses 7.71 tons of oil equivalents (toes)[3] of energy (the average Brit 3.8, the Swede 5.65 and the Senegalese 0.25), which corresponds to 90 MWh, i.e. the energy in the annual food consumption for 77 persons, or if we calculate with the twenty percent that we actually use for work it would correspond to roughly 380 persons. On the other hand there are also energy losses for the conversion of external energy to useful work. If we assume that it is forty percent we land at 150 persons.

So depending on how we count, each American has somewhere between 75 and 400 “energy slaves” working for him or her, and the richer ones have thousands. The global average energy use is of course lower, and represents figures between 18 and 90, which translated to the total population would mean somewhere between 120 and 600 billion energy slaves. In that perspective it is certainly no surprise that we have taken over this place! Another way of looking at it, and also to put in an economic perspective, is that a barrel of oil represents the energy of 25,000 hours of human toil, i.e. 14 persons working a year with normal Western labour standards. The cost for pumping the oil is not more than a few dollars per barrel, but even with an oil price of many hundred dollars per barrel, it is very cheap even compared to human slave labour. The beauty of the oil slaves is that we don’t have to feed them at all. The slaves of the past, even under huge oppression and extortion took most of the feed for themselves, just to survive. With this perspective, our current wealth is easily understood and de-mystified. Even hundreds of years ago, the person that had hundreds of others working solely for him, could lead a comfortable life, long before industrial society and capitalism.

[1] Making energy calculations is tedious if for no other reason that so many different units are used and sometimes in-energy and out-energy in process are confused or it is not clear what is referred to. So there are may possible errors in the calculation presented here, and the main reason to present the calculation instead of just giving the figure is to be transparent, and perhaps that a brain better than mine can present more solid figures in the future.

[2] 1kWh = 3.18 MJ = 860 kcal.

[3] a toe is a common unit for energy and express the amount of energy released when a ton of oil is burnt. 1 toe = 42 GJ = 11 MWh = 10 Gcal.


(I have posted something similar one and a half year ago, but these figures are updated)

Other major postings about energy:

Our energy debt

Humans and energy, the long view



What about a few more people in farming?

One doesn't have to be an economist to realise that we value something higher that is in short supply than something that is abundant. For a long time nature was seen as unlimited, just for us to exploit as we saw fit. Up to the industrial revolution exploitation was fairly proportionate to the growing population. With the industrial revolution we expand exploitation through the application of energy and technology at a raging pace. But we can see that resources are depleted and that we need to take better care of them. At the same time our population has exploded.

Not that I think we should compare humans and trees but to put it a bit provocatively: As we have more and more people and less and less nature, we have to value nature higher and people less, or at least human labour less."Saving" nature must have priority over saving labour. A question is how we make a system of regulations and incentives to cater for that, a system that doesn't erode respect for human rights and human values?Just look at employment in the USA: 9.6 million were employed in food services (restaurants, bars, catering) and 1.5 million in food manufacturing, 15.3 million in retail, compared to just above 2 million in the agriculture sector.

This simply makes no sense. There must be something fundamentally wrong with a system that employs more people flipping hamburgers than taking care of the planet...

Table 28: US employment by sector 1998-2018

US Employment by major industry sector, 1998, 2008, and projected 2018

Industry sector

Percent distribution

1998

2008

2018

Non-agriculture wage and salary

90.1

91.3

91.7

Goods-producing, excluding agriculture

17.3

14.2

12.9

Mining

0.4

0.5

0.4

Construction

4.4

4.8

5.1

Manufacturing

12.5

8.9

7.4

Services-providing

72.8

77.2

78.8

Utilities

0.4

0.4

0.3

Wholesale trade

4.1

4.0

3.7

Retail trade

10.4

10.2

9.6

Transportation and warehousing

3.0

3.0

3.0

Information

2.3

2.0

1.9

Financial activities

5.3

5.4

5.2

Professional and business services

10.8

11.8

13.2

Educational services

1.6

2.0

2.3

Health care and social assistance

8.7

10.5

11.9

Leisure and hospitality

8.0

8.9

8.8

Other services

4.1

4.2

4.3

Federal government

2.0

1.8

1.7

State and local government

12.2

13.1

12.8

Agriculture wage and salary

1.0

0.8

0.7

Agriculture self-employed and unpaid family workers

0.8

0.6

0.5

Non-agriculture self-employed and unpaid family worker

6.6

6.2

6.0

Other

1.4

1.1

1.1

Source: Bartsch 2009, Employment Projections Program, U.S. Department of Labor, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Growing inequality, between people, between countries, between region, between urban and rural.



In absolute terms, some 900 million live on daily income of below US$1.08 (the World Bank’s lowest poverty threshold) and some 2.1 billion below US$2.15 per day, i.e. almost one third live on “almost nothing”; they earn per year less than I earn per day and what some charge per hour of their work, and yet very few earn per minute. The proportion of poor people shrank from 37 percent to 30 percent 2002; most of the improvement was in China. In Africa south of Sahara 51 percent are poor (World Bank 2007). Seen over a longer term, things are not moving in the right direction, on the contrary. David Landes estimates that today the difference in income per head between the richest nations, such as Switzerland and the poorest, such as Mozambique, is about 400 to 1. Two hundred and fifty years ago, the difference was perhaps 5 to 1 and the difference between Europe and India and China was perhaps less than 2 to 1 (Radkau 2008).


There are also significant differences within countries The Economist writes about growing regional inequality in the UK the difference between GDP per person in the richest region is almost ten times as high as in the poorest (well the definition of region in the UK case is a bit strange compared to the US, in the US they used states, but in the UK they used some substantially smaller units and of course you get more disparity the smaller units you use...). In the USA the difference in income between the District of Columbia and Mississippi is five times, and increasing. Shanghai in China is set to overtake Mississippi in 2015 and people there already earns more than a quarter och the regions of the UK and Italy. And in most countries the gap between rural and urban areas is increasing. See the graph from the World Bank Development report of 2008.


Good farming needs a good society

A new discussion paper from the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) calls for a rapid shift from conventional, industrial, monoculture-based and high-external-input dependent agriculture towards mosaics of sustainable production systems.

The paper, ‘Assuring Food Security in Developing Countries under the Challenges of Climate Change: Key Trade and Development Issues of a Fundamental Transformation of Agriculture’, points out that such sustainable (regenerative) production systems, such as organic agriculture could considerably improve the productivity of small-scale farmers, and the adaptation benefits of sustainable agriculture could help farmers face the challenges of climate change to food security.

This is not the first and not the last paper to point this out. The failure of "conventional" industrial, non-organic farming to deliver either sufficient food or income and its destruction of the environment are obvious reasons to look for something else. One of the big merits of this paper is that it doesn't stop at discussion methods. Transformation of farming is not about methods and technologies in the first place. The author, Ulrich Hoffmann writes:

The current structures in global agricultural input and output markets do not ease, but rather complicate the required fundamental transformation of agricultural production methods and consumption patterns. Huge price distortions, considerable externalities, market and policy failures, as well as powerful commercial interests create a “minefield” for constructive action being (unilaterally) undertaken at national level. Without a reform of international trade and investment policies that are really supportive of ecological agriculture national-level action may remain ineffective.

There is generally too much emphasis on and simplistic overestimation of the potential of technological development for agricultural transformation. This will only give false hope and excuses for doing nothing really fundamental. In fact, only few problems in agriculture are mainly caused by a lack of technology, many are related to social, economic and cultural issues that require structural changes, not techno-fixes. It is therefore critical to first of all define what problems are best solved by changing legal frameworks, trade policies, incentive structures or human behaviour and, second, what contribution technology could make within this very context.

Good farming needs a good society, and vice versa!