Saturday, April 23, 2011

The complicated story of meat

So many want so simple answers. Is meat good or bad for the environment? Does it take away food from poor people? Sorry, there is no such simple answer. It is one thing if you don't want to kill animals, or support a system that kill animals at all. That is a ethical position which obviously can be discussed as such (I am not going to in this posting though). It is quite another story to say that meat is bad for other reasons. I believe it is simply not possible to make such statements. Fish can be produced in a nice way in small scale ponds integrated with farming and it can be produced (rather consumed) from deep-sea fishing, depleting the fish stocks, using huge amounts of energy. Lettuce can be produced in heated green-houses, consuming disastrous amounts of energy compared with its energy content. Grain can be produced in monocultures with irrigation depleting ground water. As little as we refrain from eating grain because some (as a matter of fact most of it) grain production is bad, should be we judge meat as it was one product. 

Global meat consumption per capita doubled between 1983 and 2005, which meant that total production increased even more as population also grew with almost 2 billion. Consumption of meat is estimated to double again between 2000 and 2050, the biggest increase in developing countries. China is today both the biggest producer and consumer (FAO 2006). Meat consumption is fairly strongly correlated to income. For an average Brazilian an increase of income with ten percent leads to an increase of meat consumption with 7 percent, but for the average American, who already eats so much meat, the same increase results in only one percent increase in meat consumption (USDA 2008). 

At any given time, there are around 4.3 billion animals in our service. Not only has the number of animals increased but their role in farms has changed. In traditional European farming, livestock was an integrated part of farming; they were a source of power and they occupied different ecological niches than the humans; they transformed nutrients, both to the field and directly to humans, from lands that were not suitable for arable farming and they supplied us with meat, milk, eggs, fibre, feather, fats and natural remedies. In many cultures, especially the pastoral cultures, livestock was and is a source of status, pride and social position.
 Livestock provides 17 percent of all energy and 33 percent of all protein for human nutrition. Meat consumption ranges from 5 kg per person and year in India to 123 kg in the United States (FAO 2006). The changes in the livestock sector influences also the arable farming as more meat is nowadays grain fed. This is particularly the case for pigs and poultry. Thirty-eight percent of all grain in the in the world is used for animal feed, in  high income countries as much as 60 percent. It takes 3 kg of grain to produce 1 kg of chicken and slightly more for pork. Ruminants, cattle, sheep and goats, are increasingly also fed by grain, something they are not well adapted to. Their main diet should be grass, which humans can’t eat.

Things are not so simple though. Globally it is assessed that it takes 1.3 to 1.4 kg of protein in grain and others sources to produce 1 kg of animal protein, but animal proteins have mostly higher quality than vegetable proteins.   Increasing consumption of animal protein is one of the easiest (admittedly not the only one) methods to rapidly improve nutrition and avoid long term damage caused by malnutrition of children, who may never develop to their full bodily or intellectual potential. Livestock is an important buffer of food and provides livelihoods for people who otherwise had no income and there is no evidence that livestock production detract food from those who currently go hungry (CAST 1999, FAO 2006). 600 million people today are engaged in small-scale livestock production and 200 million people live on pastoralism. This kind of animal production uses ecological niches that would not be suitable for arable farming. Ruminants graze pastures that are no good for arable farming, e.g. to steep, too dry, to cold. Small-scale pig or poultry rearing is based on waste products from field or kitchen, sometime from food processing (e.g. pigs getting whey or distiller’s wash). That kind of livestock production doesn’t really compete with production of food for humans. In addition, there are 400 million heads of livestock used as draft animals, and their role is mainly to help humans to grow more food for themselves, even if they also, mostly, also end up on our tables. (FAO 2007, Worldwatch Institute 2006, Erb and others 2009). We have seen in the case of the first agriculture revolution in Europe that integration of livestock in the farm production, including the growing of fodder on arable land, actually increased production tremendously, both of feed and food.

Industrial livestock production is, however, the opposite to the traditional systems, it needs a lot of capital and nature resources, water consumption is big. To produce 1 kg of beef 100,000 litres of water is used. Energy use is also high; a calorie of beef requires thirty-three times as much energy to produce than one calorie of potatoes. Large scale ranching might be better in many of these regards, but instead poses threats to other valuable ecosystems e.g. from forests that are cleared for grazing; A big share of the increased meat production in Brazil is from the rainforest zone (FAO 2007, Worldwatch Institute 2006). 

What about green house gases?
Methane is emitted from ruminants, from paddy rice production and from manure. Knowledge is still scarce and incomplete for many aspects of methane emissions, e.g. how the feeding influence methane emissions or how one can reduce methane emissions from paddy rice. Rice production with no or less flooding, e.g. the SRI system[1], release less methane than the normal practices. The methane emission is from the rice plant itself (up to 90%) and there are variety differences that could be exploited (FAO 2003). Intensification of livestock systems will lead to higher emissions from manure handling, but is claimed to lead to less methane per produced unit of meat or milk[2]. But we also need to relate the emissions from the domesticated ruminants with the wild fauna they have replaced. In some areas cattle, sheep and goats have replaced herds of buffalo, deer and bison, animals that also are ruminants and emit methane. On the American prairies there were 30 million bison two hundred years ago (Chapman and Reiss 1999) and the number of cows today are more or less the same. Presumably cows are eating more, despite their smaller size, because of their high production.  Research has shown that permanent pastures, such as the Hungarian puszta, can accumulate organic matter for centuries and thereby be substantial carbon sinks and to some extent balance the methane emissions from grazing cows (SvD 2008). The methane emissions of a typical African cow are, according to researchers at the International Livestock Research Institute, normally offset by carbon sequestration in their pastures (Maarse 2010). In addition, if land can not be used for pasture it has three other destinations, converted into forest, left idle or converted into farm land. The last alternative leads inevitably to more carbon emissions; the average loss of soil carbon was 59% according to a meta-analysis of 80 reports on conversion of grassland to cropland (FAO 2009). Therefore, it is doubtful if one can count the metabolism of ruminants like any other factor. 

Energy efficiency
A report from a “meat-negative” organization, Friends of the Earth, says:
“It should also be noted that extensive livestock systems with large input-output ratios are not necessarily inefficient. The efficiency measure (input-output ratio) is based on the assumption that animal protein is the major output of livestock systems, a perspective which fails to account for the utility of livestock in less developed regions where livestock fulfils a huge range of functions besides production of protein-rich food for human consumption. In low input agriculture, livestock is required to provide power for agriculture and transport and indispensable for the management of nutrients. A crucial function of livestock is the ability of ruminants to convert biomass not digestible by humans into food for humans, for example, biomass from waste lands or semi-deserts. Thus, livestock systems that appear to be inefficient due to their input-output ratio may in fact represent well-adapted, highly efficient production systems in their respective local contexts.”(Erb and others 2009). 

Water efficiency
It is well known that a lot of water is used to produce meat. But many misses a point. Pastoral meat production in dry places does use a lot of water (as rainfall), but there is not enough water per area unit to support farming, instead the animals walk around and eat the scarce grass and thereby make use of it. Again, industrial farming is quite something different. 
 
--------------
From this brief overview, it should be clear that one can’t make general statements of the effect of eating meat. Most of the criticism of how meat is produced is targeting two different production systems: grazing of cattle in the rainforests zones and the industrial grain-based feeding in richer countries, but this has almost no relevance to large parts of the livestock production, and certainly not for the pastoralist systems. Still, the total increased pressure on nature resources caused by the combination of growth of population and growth of meat consumption is worrying.
 


[1]       System of Rice Intensification, see more on http://ciifad.cornell.edu/sri/
[2]       The evidence for this seems weak and few. To measure actual emissions from the two ends of the cow in practical experiments is complicated and the empirical materials is therefore very thin.





Friday, April 22, 2011

Our drinking water: a toxic brew?



Most countries don’t systematically follow drug residues in drinking water and there are also no maximum residue thresholds. In the USA, at least one contaminant was detected in seventy-five percent of the groundwater wells tested; in virtually all the streams and stream sediments tested; in about 80% of the estuarine sediments tested; in about 80% of the freshwater fish tested and in nearly all of the salt-water fish tested (H. John Heinz III Center 2008). 

N.J. water contains traces of daily life
Drink a glass of water in New Jersey and you'll likely get more than you expect: prescription drugs, preservatives, caffeine, even a by-product of nicotine. Hundreds of these compounds, the residue of our chemical-intensive society, have been found in tap water around the state. Meanwhile, epilepsy drugs, deodorants, and other compounds have been discovered in minute amounts in 30 of New Jersey's brooks and rivers. From the Peckman River in West Paterson to the Wallkill in Sussex, researchers found traces of antibiotics, flame retardants, artificial colours, and fuel additives. Carbamazepine, a painkiller; AHTN, a fragrance in consumer products; and prometon, a herbicide, were most common. Two of the sites - the Passaic and Ramapo rivers - supply water to more than 1 million customers in North Jersey. The medicines and other chemicals were discovered in such tiny concentrations that many scientists think they pose no risk. Still, researchers admit that no one knows for sure. Many of the compounds have been studied in high doses, but not at low concentrations ingested over months, years, or a lifetime. Even less understood are the chemical cocktails now forming as they mix in the environment. "The question is, 'Is this something the body deals with at low levels, metabolizes, and there's no problem? Or is this something that accumulates in the body?' We just don't know," said Brian Buckley, the Rutgers chemist who led the four-year drinking water study. "To be honest, we are just starting to deal with the question." (North Jersey News 2003).


 Of 62 big waterworks in the USA, only 28 had tested their water for drug residues by the mid 2000s. New York, Houston, Chicago and Miami had never tested their water. Those that do test find a disturbing reality. In Philadelphia 56 different drugs were found in the drinking water and 63 in the water source. In San Francisco’s drinking water there are sexual hormones, in Washington 6 different drugs (USA Today 2008). Purification of water to get rid of the drugs might cost in the range of 200 dollar per inhabitant and year (UNT 2008).

Among the human medications found in water in the USA are antidepressants, medications for high blood pressure and diabetes, anticonvulsants, steroid medications, oral contraceptives, hormone replacement therapy medications, codeine, non-prescription pain relievers, chemotherapy drugs, heart medications, and antibiotics (President’s Cancer Panel 2010). 

Our drinking water doesn't only contain prescription drugs, but pesticides as well. In most countries there is no systematic follow up of pesticides in nature and in no country there is monitoring of all active substances; what is found is still frightening enough. Eighty percent of all rivers in the USA contain pesticide residues. Sixty percent of all wells have residues. The proportion contaminated wells was almost as high in urbanized areas, due to use in home gardens, gravel or stone paths, golf courses etc. In France, pesticides are found in all rivers and half of all water sources had at least traces of them. Of the fifty substances that are checked in the Netherlands, two thirds were found in ground water (OECD 2001). 20 pesticides were found in groundwater used by 3.5 million people in the Santa Ana River watershed. On the great plains in the USA researchers detected two insecticides and 27 herbicides in reservoir water. Water treatment removed from 14 to 86% of individual herbicides. Drinking water contained 3–15 herbicides (average, 6.4).

Engineering the globe: trusting the hand that flip the switch


Climate change has triggered ideas for large scale engineering of global systems. Large-scale ‘technological fixes’ fall into two categories. Carbon dioxide removal (CDR) techniques are designed to extract CO2 from the atmosphere. Solar radiation management (SRM) techniques are intended to reflect a portion of the sun’s light back into space. CDR is based on biological, chemical or geological carbon sequestration. SRM is based on natural effects observed in the atmosphere following volcanic eruptions. A proposal for ‘sunshade’ geo-engineering consists of the installation of space-based sun shields, or reflective mirrors, to deflect a proportion of incoming solar radiation before it reaches the atmosphere. Sunlight deflectors would be placed in near-Earth orbits or near the Lagrange point, about 1.5 million kilometers above the planet, where the gravitational pull of Earth and the sun are equal. An array of sunshades in this position would pose less threat to orbiting satellites than would near-Earth objects (UNEP 2010b, the Economist 2010b). If anything, these proposals underline the severity of the situation as well as how little we really know. They also give new perspectives on power. As Andre Matthews, an anthropologist at the University of California puts it, it is not just a matter of constructing a switch, it is a matter of constructing a hand you trust to flip it (the Economist 2010b). We should also realise how little we understand and realise that the risks of such global large scale engineering are huge and totally unpredictable. 

It is already a fact that we change many of the planet's systems enormously, but in the same way as most of these changes are a result of many small things (the car you drive, the meat you eat etc), also the solutions are to be found there rather than in macro engineering.   

UNEP 2010b, UNEP Year Book 2010
The Economist 2010b, We all want to change the world, 3 April 2010


Thursday, April 21, 2011

Wanted; someone breaking the rules

The combination of Swedish and Portuguese can give quite interesting English.
EXPRESSION OF INTEREST CONSULTANCY SERVICES FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A TRAFFIC VIOLATION
I am seriously contemplating putting in an offer for a smaller violation. I am almost a specialist in breaking the local rules with my bicycle. Have to amend my CV...

Monday, April 18, 2011

Sustainable coffee is increasing, but only 35% is sold as such.

Markets are growing rapidly across all Voluntary standards Initiatives (VSI), in all sectors reviewed, at rates far beyond the growth of markets for conventional products. The production of VSI compliant goods is now reaching significant levels of market penetration, accounting for over 10 per cent of global production across several of the sectors surveyed.

Forestry
- The land area covered by global sustainable forestry initiatives (FSC and PEFC) has grown by a total of 232 per cent over the past five years and, at 341,703,696 hectares, accounted for 18 per cent of global managed forests (nearly 9 per cent of global forested land) by the end of 2009.

Coffee
- Over the past five years, sustainable coffee sales have grown by 433 per cent and, at 457,756 metric tons, accounted for 8 per cent of global exports in 2009.
- Global supply of sustainable coffee, however, is still significantly higher than demand, with supply reaching 1,243,257 metric tons, or 17 per cent of global production.
- Reported premiums for sustainable coffees for 2009 ranged from US$0.025 to US$0.405 per pound, with most premiums falling in the US$.05 to US$.10 per pound range.

Bananas
- From 2007 to 2009, sustainable banana sales have grown by 63 per cent and, at 3,480,565 metric tons,
accounted for approximately 20 per cent of world exports by 2009.


This and much more you can read in a new report from the IISD,
The State of Sustainability Initiatives Review 2010: SUSTAINABILITY AND TRANSPARENCY

Japan: the tragedy has a face

I got an email from a friend in Japan, She writes:
> We already lost numerous farmlands from TSUNAMI. In addition to the
> disaster, Fukushima Nuclear Power Plant has, and is going to affect more
> farmland, of course organic farms also.
>
> You might already know that a farmer had committed suicide because he
> found his organic vegetables were contaminated by radiation effects. He
> has been organic farmer more than 30 years; his life was all about
> producing safe, careful, ethical foods. It is just such a pain.

No further comments.

Saturday, April 16, 2011

India: The poor will pay the bill for climate change

There are a number of reasons to believe that the costs of climate change will not be borne equally across income groups. First, regional variation is expected in future warming as well as in the climate sensitivity of agricultural production. Irrigated areas, for instance, may be wealthier and, at the same time, less vulnerable to rising temperatures. Secondly, households differ in their ownership of agricultural assets, notably land, as well as in their human capital and allocation of labor. The returns on land and labor (of different types) will probably respond differently to climate change. Thirdly, households will be exposed in varying degrees to changes in food prices that are likely to occur with global warming. Urban households tend to be net buyers of food to a much greater extent than rural households (as are non-farm households within rural areas), leaving them relatively worse o when prices rise.

A recent research paper from the World Bank analyzes how changes in the prices of land, labor, and food induced by modest temperature increases over the next three decades will affect household-level welfare in India. The authors predict a substantial fall in agricultural productivity, even allowing for farmer adaptation. Overall, the welfare costs of climate change fall disproportionately on the poor. This is true in urban as well as in rural areas, but, in the latter sector only after accounting for the effects of rising world cereal prices. The results suggest that poverty in India will be roughly 3–4 percentage points higher after thirty years of rising temperatures than it would have been had this warming not occurred.

The report also says that:
The substantial fall in agricultural productivity (17 percent overall) that we predict as a result of warming will translate into a much more modest consumption decline for the majority of households. This is because these households derive the bulk of their income from wage employment and (rural) wages are estimated to fall by only a third as much as agricultural productivity. 
But here I loose the reasoning: If agriculture productivity is supposed to fall, realistically prices would go up. And if wages are also supposed to fall those poor that derive most of their income from wage labour must suffer hard from falling wages and increased food prices. Perhaps I am missing some part of the argument? 



Monday, April 11, 2011

"When collapse happens, it’s not linear and neat. "

With the collapse of the financial system, and subsequent government rescue, we understand what happens when complex systems collapse.  As we enter the second “food crisis” in three years, alleviated only by the greatest economic contraction since the great depression, we would be wise to learn some critical lessons from the financial collapse: When collapse happens, it’s not linear and neat.  It expands through the interconnections of the complex system in ways that are difficult to anticipate and impossible to manage.
This was written by by former JPMorgan Managing Director John Fullerton from The Capital Institute as a reflection from his participation at a US department of Agriculture Conference.  A short piece worth reading. 

Sunday, April 10, 2011

Water footprint: How much water is there in a 0.5 l soda

Well you might believe it is like 0.495 l. But according to the water foodprint methodology it is some 170 liters to 310 liters....
I posted something on water pricing the other day, and here comes a bit more on water.
There is the concept of water foot print or why not call it "waterprint", which is an indicator of freshwater use that looks at both direct and indirect water use of a consumer or producer. Recently a standard for the calculation of water footprint is developed

Some facts and figures

  • The production of one kilogram of beef requires 16 thousand litres of water. There is a huge variation around this global average. The precise footprint of a piece of beef depends on factors such as the type of production system and the composition and origin of the feed of the cow.

  • To produce one cup of coffee we need 140 litres of water. This, again, is a global average. 
    There are of course differences between countries, but the water footprint doesn't differ as much between poor and rich countries as many other resources uses.  The Americans use about four times as much water per person than the people in the countries with the smallest water footprint, e.g. in Yemen. The water footprint of China is about 700 cubic meter per year per capita. Only about 7% of the Chinese water footprint falls outside China.Japan with a footprint of 1150 cubic meter per year per capita, has about 65% of its total water footprint outside the borders of the country. The USA water footprint is 2500 cubic meter per year per capita.

Derk Kuiper is executive director of the Water Footprint Network, an organisation established in the Netherlands in 2008 to promote sustainable and equitable water use worldwide by promoting the water footprint. in an Interview he says that:

 In the sustainability assessment, water footprint uses the concept of sustainability boundaries – which is about how to actually sustain the environmental and social benefits associated with your water. And if you start pricing those you can actually balance them much better against the economic activities that are taking place on the basis of water.
An interesting, and for me a bit disturbing, perspective is that: 
It is generally accepted that emissions of greenhouse gasses, such as CO2 from fossil energy carriers, are responsible for anthropogenic impacts on the climate system. In this context, there has been a remarkable shift in policy attitudes towards CO2-neutral energy carriers such as biomass. The production of biomass for food and fibre in agriculture requires about 86% of the worldwide freshwater use. In many parts of the world, the use of water for agriculture competes with other uses such as urban supply and industrial activities. In a scenario of increasing degradation and decline of water resources, a shift from fossil energy towards energy from biomass puts additional pressure on freshwater resources. says the Waterfootprint.org

Farmers don't want to pay - surprised?
With overexploitation of water rife in agriculture, making farmers pay real prices for publicly managed irrigation systems could push them to avoid waste and adopt more sustainable practices, argues the European Environment Agency (EEA).According to the agency, water pricing is "the core mechanism" for making agricultural water use more efficient, and research shows that farmers reduce irrigation and adopt water efficiency practices when illegal extraction is effectively policed and water paid for by volume.
The EU agricultural association Copa-Cogeca recognises that agriculture is a big user of water, especially in Southern Europe, but underlines that "the upward trend for use of water for irrigation has slowed down in several countries during recent years," while "water-use efficiency in agriculture is improving every year" due to the modernisation of irrigation systems. Copa-Cogeca is wary about water pricing, which "can bring about more negative effects to the agricultural sector than to other economic sectors, which can more easily pass on the costs for the use of water resources to the end-consumer," it said. Read more

Developing countries to do 65% of emission reductions.

It is amazing that the rich countries first think they can pollute and exploit the nature resources of the world, and then when things get rough, they ask the poor countries to save and reduce their pollution. Rich countries consume in the range of 10 times more resources than poor countries, and rich people in rich countries consumer hundreds, perhaps thousand as much resources than poor people in poor countries. And then we moan over their population being a threat to the environment.....

A Bolivian ambassador, Ambassador Solon, stated recently that
The gap in the abatement is 7.4 to 5.3 Gt. of CO2e (53% to 38%)
• This can lead us to a 4°C to 5°C increase in the global temperature
• Developing countries are going to do more emission reductions than
developed countries (54% vs. 46 % in LEP and 57% vs. 45% in
HEP)
• The offsets can be 16% of global nominal pledges (1.1 Gt. CO2e for
Lower End Pledges)
• Because of offsets the abatement can be only 5.5 Gt. for the Lower
End Pledges.
• The gap in the abatement will be higher because of offsets: 8.5 Gt.
for the Lower End Pledges. (61 % of the 14 Gt. of CO2e)
• With offsets developing countries will do even more effort than
developed countries (65% versus 35%)

He based his presentation on the following two sources. I have not crosschecked them.
STOCKHOLM ENVIROMENT INSTITUTE, The implications of International Greenhouse Gas Offsets on Global Climate Change, http://seis-us.org/ publications/id/380 
UNEP, The Emissions Gap Report, Are the Copenhagen Accord Pledges Sufficient to Limit Global Warming to 2 ºC or 1,5ºC?, www.unep.org/publications/ ebooks/emissionsgapreport/

Friday, April 8, 2011

An economics of water: Why “Free” Is the Wrong Price for Water

I just came accross an interesting paper Change this Why "Free" Is the Wrong Price for Water—Even If You Live on $1 a Day 
 some extracts:
Although we don’t often consider it, free isn’t that great. The lack of a price—on water or on any other resource—leads to all kinds of inequities and inefficiencies. Water is the most vital substance in every aspect of human endeavor, but the economics of water are a mash-up of tradition, wishful thinking, and poor planning.  In Las Vegas, the water supply is in such desperately critical shape that the water utility pays homeowners $40,000 per acre to rip up their lawns. And yet Las Vegas has among the lowest residential water rates in the country. A typical family’s bill there is $23.62 a month. In Atlanta, the same amount of water would cost you $50.


The average home in the U.S. pays $3.24 for 1,000 gallons of water.
The average home in Las Vegas pays $2.71 for 1,000 gallons of water.
A farmer in the Imperial Valley pays six cents for 1,000 gallons of water.
And here’s the really astonishing thing: The farmer in the Imperial Valley is using exactly the same water as the guys in Las Vegas
 Exactly HOW to solve the use of water is another question though. I remembered visiting Namibia (very dry place) and they had staggered payments, so the people paid very little for the first liters, but it was prohibitively expensive to fill your pool or water your lawn. That made a lot of sense. A privatization of water resources would lead to better management, but I believe that that is a dangerous path to tread. I guess it is about the so called "tragedy of the commons" - a concept that often is misinterpreted to mean that commons are bad, that is not at all what was intended by Hardin when he coined it. It was that commons need to be managed that was his point. Privatize them is just one way of doing that. Mostly commons are managed perfectly fine by communities. I think the fluid nature of water makes it, together with the air, the most difficult commons to manage. Public waterworks certainly should start to price money. Overall, all nature resource use should be charged for in my opinion, just to keep our consumption in check. If this is done by the public sector it will get an awful lot of money which partly can be redistributed to ensure that poor people are not harmed by these policies. Ultimately the poor use a lot less anyway - that is the definition of poverty in the first place....

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Post peak oil and post-growth, the same?

I updated an earlier post about Japan as an example of a post-growth economy.

Carbon prices will not drive innovations

Cap and trade or carbon taxes may be useful to make us save energy but it will not drive the kinds of innovations that are needed according to a new study.

It is commonly argued that a high carbon price will drive innovations. e.g the EU Climate Commissioner said that last year and famed Harvard University professor Michael Porter says "A carbon tax would lead to a rethinking of energy use, drive innovation in the green economy and yield profits for "first movers," 

This conventional wisdom is now contradicted:
A carbon price can be a useful tool to nudge the adoption of mature technologies, but it does little to pull forth disruptive new technology or stimulate the advance of basic knowledge upon which new technology is built."
Says a recent report from the ITIF . The report shows by many examples that innovations of the kind and scale we need to cope with climate change, are beyond what markets can sort out.
In the current energy and climate debate, most advocates argue that putting a price on carbon emissions through either a carbon tax or a cap-and-trade program is the key to spurring breakthrough energy innovation. This conventional wisdom is based on the notion that higher dirty energy prices will provide the right market signals to entrepreneurs, who will then develop breakthrough clean alternatives. But advocates of the price approach provide little to no evidence for this notion, for the simple reason that there is little to no evidence for it. In fact, over the past century, in major innovation after major innovation, the pursuit of research and public support for early-stage technology and markets, and not price signals, have driven breakthrough innovation.
Real break-through innovations originate in research-driven technological development. Markets drives innovations in mature technologies where market barriers apart from price are minimal. Apart from being valuable in developing strategies for climate change, and play down the value of carbon pricing for driving innovation, I think the research is also challenging the frequent claims of how superior markets are to drive innovations. Antibiotics, internet, most progress in aviation and nuclear industries have been results of public funded research, and certainly not by entrepreneurs.

The study does recognize that carbon pricing, whether cap and trade or tax or something else, can encourage saving by consumers and drive technologies oriented to that. Also uptake of existing technologies that are close to being competitive can be speed up by carbon pricing. Critically, the authors note that a carbon price could also be used to generate needed revenue for targeted investments in clean energy innovation.

Other articles on similar topic: the Greens in Australia

Australia should be spending $2.5 billion a year on new low-emissions technologies by 2017, a doubling of current expected expenditure, climate change adviser Ross Garnaut says.  Prof Garnaut argues there's a case for "exceptionally large fiscal support for firms that invest in research, development and commercialisation of new low-emissions technologies" over the next decade. He says pricing carbon will drive innovation but "on its own it will not increase it by enough". reports thewest in Australia
Putting a price on carbon emissions will have limited environmental benefits and will not drive the level of technical innovation required to tackle climate change.That was the message for delegates at the close of the Tyndall Centre's inaugural conference on financing green technology earlier this week as Dr Jonathan "Jack" Frost of Johnson Matthey Fuel Cells argued that, regardless of more recent difficulties with emission trading schemes, carbon pricing initiatives had a history of failing to deliver environmental benefits.writes Businessgreen.
A recent report about the EU carbon trading scheme confirms that the scheme is not sufficient to drive innovations.

But what of complimentary instruments such as performance or regulatory standards and carbon finance mechanisms which aim to create economic incentives? These instruments, while they have been shown to be effective at producing favorable environmental outcomes, do not necessarily drive innovation in the marketplace. For example, as in the prior cases of sulphur dioxide emissions and leaded gasoline, emitters were simply able to invest in “off-the-shelf” technologies to deal with the externalities. It is important to remember that regulatory certainty around these environmental pollutants did not result in new innovation because the technological alternatives were already in existence. Furthermore, the cost of removing sulfur or lead as an environmental practice was virtually invisible to consumers; a move that seems unlikely in the case of CO2 and manmade greenhouse gas. For greenhouse gas emissions, which can conceptually be treated as an environmental pollutant, the required off-the-shelf alternatives (for existing infrastructure) arguably do not yet exist or are not yet cost competitive ! Case in point: it is not yet possible to retrofit a coal burning power plant with a carbon capture and storage unit. writes carboninsights.

Putting a price on carbon dioxide emissions will not be enough to drive the innovation needed to clean up dirty energy systems, according to Bruegel, a think tank based in Brussels, and Harvard economists.Reinhilde Veugelers, a senior research fellow at Bruegel, warned on Monday that a “private green innovation machine has not yet taken off” and that private companies still were not making environmental innovations their core goal.Ms. Veugelers cited figures from the World Intellectual Property Organization showing that just 2.2 percent of all patent applications between 2000 and 2006 were for environmental applications. She said the global electricity sector “was almost absent” in terms of green innovation. Reported The New York Times in 2009.




Tuesday, April 5, 2011

Disasters: rich blindness and poor people drown.

It is no surprise to me, but a surprise coming from the World Bank:
Assuming that capital productivity is higher in areas at risk from natural hazards (such as coastal zones or flood plains), this paper shows that rapid development in these areas—and the resulting increase in disaster losses—may be the consequence of a rational and well-informed trade-off between lower disaster losses and higher productivity.....These results also suggest that the overall risk — i.e. mean annual losses — can increase with time, and even faster than wealth, in spite of continuously improving protection. A consequence of these findings is that future increase in disaster losses might be difficult to avoid.....
The more interesting stuff comes later:

All risks are not linked to rational choices, however. We showed that imperfect information and
myopic expectations can amplify risk-taking behaviors. This effect can be reinforced by other
sub-optimalities. In particular, some economic agents have little flexibility in their localization
choices, like the poorest households who locate in informal settlements in developing-country
cities.
What this means in more plain speak is "myopic expectations" is the most revered short term interest of profit, the so called invisible hand that is supposed to make everybody happy in the end. And that the effect of this, like always, hurt poor people most.

So in essence what their research show is the profit motives are not giving an optimal result or an optimal resource allocation and that the cost of failure will have to be born by the poor. Well, we knew that already, but it is good to have World Bank papers to prove the point...It also shows the inherent danger of too complex economic systems and the danger of trying to "compete" with nature. When you build a dyke it protects you from the flood, but once that dyke burts, you are worse off than without the dyke. 

Download the paper
 

Monday, April 4, 2011

It takes more energy to eat than to farm


The increase of energy use in agriculture was in particular very rapid in the period after the second world war and the first oil price chock 1973; while labour force was reduced to half between 1952 and 1972 in England, energy use tripled. In the USA energy use decreased from mid 1970s to mid 1980s as a response to increased oil prices, thereafter it has stabilized. Looking at the whole food chain however, energy use has constantly increased. In pre-industrial and semi-industrial agriculture systems, most of the food is sold, eaten and prepared close to where it is produced, but the modern food chains are highly centralized and globalized. And the energy ratio is just getting worse and worse. In industrial countries between 10 and 15 times more energy is used in the food system than what is contained in the food we end up eating (Uhlin 1997, Hendricksson 1994).

A big part of the energy consumption is caused by the consumers buying, storage and preparation of food. In Sweden 1997, agriculture production represented 15-19 percent, processing 17-20 percent; distribution and retail 20-29 percent and consumption 38-45 percent of the total energy use in the food chain. 7-11 percent of the total energy is consumed by the much discussed transports, and here it is in particular the final stretch that counts. A person driving the car 5 kilometres for shopping uses a lot more energy per food unit than a ship with meat or soy from Argentina. Also, in some developing countries consumption takes the lion's share of energy use; in this case, it is mainly cooking over an open fire that takes energy. 1,500 kWh (corresponding to a bit more than a cubic meter of firewood) is used per capita for cooking, which is somewhere between half and one third of what is used per capita for cooking in Sweden or the USA (Uhlin 1997). Cooking represents more than a fifth of the total energy consumption in Africa and Asia and in some countries, cooking represent up to over 90% of household energy consumption (IEA 2006).  In the absence of new policies, the number of people relying. Another interesting observation is that the use of energy for cooking is more than the total energy in the food. So while farming in developing countries and traditional systems is energy efficient, cooking is not.

Other values of food

Energy ratios in agriculture give a interesting perspective but conclusions can’t be taken into the extreme. Firstly we are, at least not yet, in a situation where we have to equal energy in food with energy in oil, nuclear power or hydro power. At a first glance, one might even consider such comparisons absurd. And they are absurd, if we think that there will be unlimited supplies of energy in the future. Not too many believe that anymore. All staple foods, i.e. the foods that have provided the bulk of the nutrition are foods with a positive energy balance in their traditional way of production. If that was not the case, they could never have been staple foods in the first place. Secondly, it is not only the calories that give value to food. In such a case we could do best keeping to sugar (and sugar cane is one of the most energy efficient crops there are). Vegetables will always be inferior to grain when it comes to energy ratios. They contain a lot of minerals and vitamins, however. Meat is not primarily consumer for its energy content but for its protein (I will discuss meat more another time). Finally, some food is eaten simply because it tastes well or for religious or cultural reasons.

and my all time favourite: 250 million energy slaves
all of them are posts derived from my book Garden Earth.

China: organic market exceeds 1 billion dollars.

There is no clear and comprehensive statistical information about the volume and value of organic production in China. There were some 2,500 certified organic producers, with more than 100,000 individual farmers in 2007. About 2 million – 3 million hectares of farmland is certified  as organic, putting China among the world’s top five organic producers, in acreage terms. Statistical data on Chinese organic production, however, vary from one source to another.

A recent report from the International Trade Center estimates that there was 2.03 million hectares of certified organic farmland in 2009. In 2008, the total value of organic production reached about RMB 16 billion (US$ 2.4 billion), with exported organic products exceeding US$ 500 million and the domestic organic market reaching US$ 1.1 billion. The remaining US$ 800 million in organic products were sold as conventional products. China’s domestic market in organic products began developing in the mid-2000s and has expanded very  rapidly, especially in the past few years when food scandals became prominent. 
Read more

WindMade

Yet another environmental standard is in the making. Now it is "Wind Made" a standard that assure that the product is made from Wind energy. The initiative is from Danish Vestas, a major wind mill producer.

The CEO of Vestas says:
"Vestas tried for years to communicate the benefits of wind to the general public: the investments we made were high; the results were fairly poor. So, we needed a new path. We concluded that we no longer could solely depend on the political system to make the necessary decisions. We needed to go further up the value chain. At the end of the day politicians are motivated by what consumers and citizens expect from them. We recognized that Vestas was too small and we didn’t have the bandwidth or the communication channels to do it ourselves. We needed to activate the B2C [business-to-consumer] giants because they’re actually the ones that have the strongest impact on and direct access to the influential and growing global middle class. So how could we actually create a new design that could build a bridge between Vestas and the whole wind industry providing knowledge to the consumers about the benefits of wind?"

The standard will be developed under the direction of the WindMade Technical Committee, consisting of representatives from WWF, Vestas Wind Systems, and PwC, among others. During the development process, the Technical Committee will gather feedback from the general public including potential participants in the WindMade Labeling Program and from consumer label standard and renewable energy experts.

Source: http://www.windmade.org/

Friday, April 1, 2011

One energy plant in the UK to use biomass equalling total UK wood production

I am a great fan of renewable energy, and also of the use of biomass for heating, electricity generation and fuel. But this is all linked to a considerable, and I mean considerable downsizing of our energy consumption. Without that we are more likely to ruin even more nature by increased use of biomass. I am now speaking about energy consumption on industrial country levels.

In a desperate search for energy that is "carbon neutral" the UK now just gave permission for the conversion of a giant power plant to be fueled by wood pellets. It will use 7 million per year. This corresponds roughly to the UK wood produciton.  This will nearly double the amount of wood pellets burned in the entire EU – 9 million tones in 2010.  The company, RWE, will receive around £400m in 'renewable energy' financial subsidies a year for this power station alone. Most of the wood to fuel British power stations will have to be imported as the Forestry Commission has calculated that only an additional 2 million tonnes of wood fuel per year could be produced from within England by 2020. This is why these facilities are based at ports like Southampton, Holyhead, Tyneside and Avonmouth, where they will receive shipments of wood from Brazil, the USA, Canada, West Africa, Russia and elsewhere. Read more, 
och här

This is the second round for British wood consumption to extol pressure on forests elsewhere. Some 150 years ago, industrialization in  England drove massive deforestation in Sweden and elsewhere, until the increased use of pit coal and steel and rapidly increasing prices of wood drove down demand.  

There is simply NO good solution to our energy needs - apart from downsizing. It will be a rough ride, in particular for densely populated countries with limited nature resources, such as England. 

Read my other posts about Biofuel 

Thursday, March 31, 2011

Organic agriculture needs to address energy

There was always a simple agrarian equation that farmers must produce more energy as food than the energy they spent on growing it. They needed to produce energy for themselves, for their young (reproducing the labour force), their old and sick dependants, for other trades people and for the rulers, who offered protection in return for taxes or a labour tithe. For a long time this energy equation remained the same. Gradually, through technical innovations, productivity increased and new lands could be tilled, thereby allowing a slow increase in population. Overall productivity per worker didn't increase so much; slash and burn farming, almost without tools, is almost as productive as farming with oxen and a plough. Three things, all linked to each other, changed this dramatically: the emergence of the capitalist market economy, industrialization and fossil fuel energy.

The production per agriculture worker in the most advanced economies has now reached 2,000 tons of grain per person year, compared to historical times when it was just a few tons; an increase in labour productivity of about a thousand fold. In the poorest countries the average value produced by a farm worker is just above 100 dollars per year. In France it is some 40,000 dollars per year. And, the gap in productivity between the rich and the poor is widening. Labour productivity in modern farming can largely be explained in terms of the command of energy resources. The modern farmer is de facto in command of a massive army of "energy slaves"; a barrel of oil represents the energy of 25,000 hours of human toil – the equivalent of 14 people working a year under normal Western labour standards. This shows that the energy efficiency of modern farming is considerably lower than in pre-industrial farming systems. Our ancestors would have starved to death if they their energy ratios were as bad as ours; industrial countries use between 10 and 15 times more energy in the food system than is contained in the food they end up eating. Organic farming is somewhat more efficient than non-organic, but organic farmers in industrialized countries also have a very energy-inefficient production.

Farmers in developing countries, have almost no access to fossil fuel energy resources. Yet they are supposed to compete with their colleagues in developed countries who use energy resources that are the equivalent of hundreds of labourers. Perverse subsidy systems, trade and food policies further bend the rules in favour of farmers in rich countries. And to make matters even worse, various kinds of "climate" or "carbon" standards are now being imposed on poor farmers. But the reality is that (with the exception of slash and burn farmers) they are performing much better than industrialized farms, regardless how we measure (per hectare, per man hour or per kg crop or meat). The organic sector should avoid repeating this way of penalising those who are already disadvantaged, and we should realise that the energy use of modern farming is highly inefficient. The only more disturbing feature in modern farming is the destruction of natural capital in the form of soil erosion. Organic farming began with a concern about the soil issue. We now need to take the energy challenge much more seriously.

This article will soon appear as a column in the magazine Ecology and Farming

Wednesday, March 30, 2011

The Magic washing machine

Hans' presentation shows the link between poverty and energy and the challenges involved in a very easy to grasp way.



What I often miss in Hans' presentations is the link to economic and political forces, which both helps to explain WHY things are like they are and also have the solutions. Nevertheless, he does a great job, and you can find much more on Gapminder

Monday, March 28, 2011

Ecosystems: Invaluable and worthless

(another extract from Garden Earth, the book)

In the middle of the 1990s, a study estimated the value of ecosystem services to some US$ 33 trillion, double the size of the world Gross Domestic Product, GDP (Hall and Klitgaard 2006). MEA doesn’t try to assign values to ecosystems and ecosystem services, but it shows with numerous examples that if we did calculate such values, many things we consider to the profitable today would not be profitable and vice versa. This is because profit is calculated by the entrepreneurs running a company and as long as they can use ecosystem services for free and as long as the degradation of the services are not paid for, this will not appear in any economic calculations. Some examples of estimated values of ecosystem services are:

- In Belize, mangrove and corral reefs produce fisheries, tourism and coastal protection for a value between 395 million and 559 million dollars annually, according to studies of World Resource Institute and World Wildlife Fund. This can be contrasted to the whole Gross Domestic Product of Belize of 1.3 billion dollars (WRI 2008)

- The value of biodiversity in New Zealand was estimated 1997 to 152 billion dollars, which can be compared to the GDP of 56 billion dollars. The valuation didn’t include theoretically potential services but only those that are known (OECD 2001).

- ‘Business as usual’ deforestation and land-use changes cause annual losses of natural capital valued at between EUR 1.3 trillion and EUR 3.1 trillion, a sum exceeding the total financial losses of Wall Street and London City during 2008, their worst year ever (Arborvitae 2010).


Let it be

In October 1999, the state of Orissa in India was battered by a super cyclone that killed almost 10,000 people and caused a massive loss of livestock and property. A researcher found that mangroves do provide important storm protection to people, livestock, and buildings. Had the mangrove forests been intact, more than 90% of the deaths due to the 1999 cyclone would have been avoided. A hectare of mangrove forest land stopped damage worth $43,000 in the district during the super cyclone. Of course, such severe storms do not occur every year. But even allowing for the fact that mangroves have no storm protection value during non-storm years, the long-term protection value of about $8,700. At the time, a hectare of cleared land was fetching $5,000. Thus, leaving mangroves as storm buffers generates more value to society than clearing them for development (Glover 2010).


How Mexican farmers get paid by American blue chips to bind carbon

To an increasing extent, systems are developed for payment of maintenance or new production of ecosystem services. Already 1996, Costa Rica introduced a system where land owners could get compensation for carbon sequestration, biodiversity, water regulation and aesthetic values. Year 2001, the payments in this program had reached 30 million dollars for a total of 280,000 hectares. Farmers in the EU and the USA are paid for all kinds of environmental services to protect landscapes, water sources, maintain or re-create biodiversity[1]. The USA pays 1.4 billion dollars annually for 13 million hectares (FAO 2007).

The possibly best know market for environmental services is the market for reduction of emissions of green house gases. There are two markets. One is government controlled and is regulated under the Kyoto Protocol, the other is a voluntary market for companies, organizations or individuals wanting to reduce their environmental footprint or making themselves “carbon neutral”. The Clean Development Mechanism under the Kyoto protocol, the EU system for emission rights and the voluntary so called “carbon[2] market” was worth some US$ 143 billion market in 2009, an increase of US$48 billion just three years earlier, so this is now one of the fastest growing markets in the world (World Bank 2010b). In Brazil’s first so called REDD (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and forest Degradation) project each family in the Juma Sustainable Development Reserve in the Amazon, each family receives US$ 28 per month if the forest remains uncut (UNEP 2010b). Farmers in the Scoltel Té-project in Chiapas (Mexico) sell carbon sequestration, in the soil and in the vegetation, for 3.30 dollar per ton. Of this 60 percent goes directly to the farmers, representing an increase of their income with between 300 dollars and 1,800 dollars, big sums for households where the average income is about 1000 dollars (World Bank 2007).

The city of New York gets the majority of its water from an area stretching 200 km north and west of the city. The authorities came to the conclusion that is was more efficient to manage the catchment area for good water quality instead of investing in a purification plant. Such a plant would cost between 6 and 8 billion dollars. The implementation of a catchment management program cost 1.5 billion. It includes measures such as purchase of some critical lands; education, support to farmers for reducing use of chemical fertilizers and synthetic pesticides according to FAO, the United National Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO 2007). Insurance and shipping companies are financing the reforestation of the Panama Canal Zone to restore freshwater flows and avoid increased costs caused by canal closures (TEEB 2010).

Global extortion or fair compensation?

The United States Treasury and Brazil have signed an agreement converting $21m of Brazilian debt into a fund to protect three tropical ecosystems. Brazil will use the money for activities to conserve protected areas, improve natural resource management and develop sustainable livelihoods for communities that rely on forests. The agreement comes under the Tropical Forest Conservation Act (TFCA) of 1998, which to date has generated $239 million to protect tropical forests in Bangladesh, Belize, Botswana, Colombia, Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Indonesia, Jamaica, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, and the Philippines (ISEAL 2010).

Taking the idea of getting paid for not using a resource to new levels, the President of Ecuador, Rafael Correa, has said that his government is prepared not to extract nearly a billion barrels of oil from Yasuní National Park, a part of the Amazon rainforest of extraordinary but fragile ecological and cultural richness. To do so, however, Ecuador will need to be compensated by the international community for its loss of oil revenue – to the tune of US$350 million per annum for the next 10 years. A conservative estimate is that exploiting the oil would bring in US$5.7 billion in present value terms, or 10% of Ecuador's GDP. With abatement[3] cost for carbon dioxide at US$14 to US$20 per ton, the cost to the world to abate these emissions will be between US$1.7 billion and US$2.4 billion for the extraction and burning, and US$909 million for deforestation, for a total between US$2.6 billion and US$3.7 billion (The Guardian 2009b).

Like with other new programs, especially when they involve money, there are potential problems and side effects, some of which are not seen initially. There are examples from India, where poor landless people have been harmed of community forest management plans, because the plans limit their access to resources to which they before had unrestricted access. Other examples when communal land has been appropriated by private owners who suddenly see a commercial interest in these environmental services. In Guyana, a private equity firm has bought the rights to 20 percent of the value of environmental services from a 370,000 hectare rainforest reserve anticipating that its carbon storage, water storage, biodiversity maintenance and rainfall regulation services will become a valuable asset in the future (Arborvitae 2010).

Should the have a price or are they invaluable?

We have seen how important ecosystems and the services they can supply are. Mostly we are not aware of the services that are provided by nature to our benefit. Their composed value is very high, notwithstanding many of them are of such a character and importance for our survival that their value simply can’t be calculated; such as supply of oxygen. We can’t even imagine how to organize the same service if the current ecosystems collapse. Ecosystem services can be more efficient, we influence them all the time. Agriculture is of course the most prominent example where we over millennia has increased the value (for us, that is), the yield, from a certain area. But the example also highlights the dangers of looking at only one ecosystem service, in this case the supply of food. It is exactly that narrow perspective that has led us to degeneration of the agriculture landscape, to erosion, to pollution in the same time as it has given us the possibility to tenfold population.

Surprisingly, there is not a very strong critique against the privatization that payment of ecosystem services actually entail, not even from normally anti-capitalist groups. On the contrary, many of them express sympathy and support programs for programs to pay farmers for ecosystem services. Probably they don’t realize that payment of ecosystem services from taxes represents a giant privatization and a transformation of nature resources and commons into commodities. As we discussed the total value of the ecosystem services probably exceed the total value of the current economy. And as more and more services are threatened, their prices will increase, fully in line with the principles of market economy. This also means that the GDP will increase and increase more, the more we deplete our resources, until they ultimately collapse.


[1] The link between the payments and the supplied service is rather weak, in particular in the EU. The levels of compensation are not calculated in any scientific or economic way, but are rather just the results of horse-trading between farmer organizations and the EU member states.

[2] The real ”carbon market” is of course the coal, gas and oil market and not the carbon dioxide green house gas emission reduction market

[3] Abatement and mitigation are used interchangeably to describe the processes by which greenhouse gases emissions can be reduced or compensated for by some other mechanism, such as carbon sequestration, carbon sinks. Adaptation refers to the process of adapting to climate change, i.e. not change it or do anything about it, but learn how to live with it.


Japan: post growth and post-peak-oil works?

This blog post has a lot of copying from of Japan: The World’s First Post-Growth Economy? at postgrowth.org
One of the problems with the post-growth movement is that it can appear theoretical. More of the ideas have been tried than you might think, but certainly they haven’t all been tried at once as a deliberate strategy. No matter how confident we might be, we lack proof that a post-growth economy is possible. Or do we? Perhaps the world already has a post-growth society, albeit an unintentional one. Here’s what Japan’s GDP has been up to for the last twenty years:

I also contrast this against the chart of Japan's energy consumption which proves my point of the intrinsical link between energy and economic growth. Japan is also a country that emits a lot less carbon per person than most other rich countries.

And yet, the lights are still on, everything still works. Literacy is high, and crime is low. Life expectancy is better than almost anywhere on earth – 82 years to the US’ 78. The trains run to the second. Unemployment is only 5%, and levels of inequality are enviable. In fact, it is living proof that growth isn’t necessary to deliver a high standard of living. And they even seem to cope with the effect of the earthquake and disaster fairly well. This because Japan is a rather well functioning society with social capital
That’s not to say that Japan is to be envied or emulated. A legacy of failed stimulus ideas has left it with big debts, and the future is as uncertain as it is anywhere. Neither is it a steady-state economy in the way that matters most – in its materials. Japan consumes considerably more than a one-planet share and is not sustainable in that sense.
The point is that for well over a decade, one of the world’s most important economies hasn’t grown. And at the end of that stint, it’s still a great place to live. So maybe Japan isn’t a failure. Maybe it’s just ahead of its time – not ‘stagnating’, but settling into the plateau of ‘enough’.
After 15 years of fretting, maybe it’s time Japan embraced its post-growth state and told the economists where to stick their theories. Professor Norihiro Kato recently suggested that Japanese youth culture was doing just that, downsizing and taking a more measured approach to consumerism. Japan’s population had already levelled off, he noted. He even suggested Japan was entering a post-growth era. “Japan is a small country” people are saying, “and we’re O.K. with small. It is, perhaps, a sort of maturity.”
Japan, whether it likes it or not, is the world’s first post-growth economy. It won’t be the last. Japan proves that growth isn’t necessary to safeguard the things that matter most in life. There’s nothing to fear in levelling out, and if the alternative is boom and bust, then the plateau is a far safer place to be. How Japanese people themselves look at it can be read at: http://www.japanfs.org/en/mailmagazine/newsletter/pages/030685.html 

Update: just a few days after this was posted, The Guardian had an article about Japan as a show case for how "post-peak-oil" could look like.  So I amended the headline of this article, to include that perspective. I had already mentioned that there is this strong link between energy growth and economic growth. Essentiallyh post-growth and post peak oil are the same, at least as long as we have an economic system as the one we have.

Saturday, March 26, 2011

Energy is the currency of the world

Adenosine triphosphate (ATP) is the universal unit of energy used in all living cells. This molecule is produced and broken down in metabolic processes in all living systems.Known as the ‘energy currency of life,’ ATP can store and transport the energy we need to do just about everything that we do. Essentially all metabolic functions of living cells require energy for operation and obtain it directly from stored ATP.

That's the stuff going on in our cells.

But the more I look into the issues I believe there is a justification to state that energy is the currency of the world at large. It is energy that flows from the sun, that starts the whole cycle of life, and all our life is dependent that. In addition, all farming is about yielding energy, and ultimately our whole industrial society is based on access to cheap fossil fuel. If it were not for the coal pits in England, there might never had been an industrial revolution nor capitalism.
There seems to be a rough overall correlation between GDP/capita and energy/capita. This is understandable, since higher productivity per individual will cause a higher energy need for each. Due to the very rapid expansion in financial "services" and housing booms in many countries there was seemingly a bigger disconnect the last twenty years than we can see historically.
Source: the World Bank.

I believe this very strong correlation is what makes the energy issue to such a hot political issue more than a technical issues. It IS about our lifestyles and it IS about our economic system at large. To challenge energy use is fundamentally to challenge capitalism. That's why even proponents of wind and solar or biomass have this tendency to oversell those technologies, because it is only if they can show that they will be adundant and cheap that you can get political acceptance for them.

But as well as sugar is energy in our body, and more energy makes a stronger person, ultimately it also leads to diabetes and obesity. Our societies are obese, not only the people.

Friday, March 25, 2011

Less Salmonella in Organic Chicken

We are always scared with that organic is less safe. The argument goes that because organic farmers don't use pesticides, parasiticides, fungicides or antibiotics, organic crops or animals will be a risk for health. I always thought that it is nonsense, but it is hard to convince folks just from your gut feeling. But again and again you find evidence that organic is even safer. The latest survey of that kind says:
The results of our study suggest that within this poultry company, the prevalence of fecal Salmonella was lower in certified-organic birds than in conventionally raised birds, and the prevalence of antimicrobial-resistant Salmonella was also higher in conventionally raised birds than in certified-organic birds.

What is perhaps more alarming is that 39.7 percent of the salmonella found in the conventional birds had resistance to no fewer than six different antibiotics. None of the salmonella from the organic birds showed antibiotic resistance.
read more

Organic egg sales are progressing says The Organic Man

Also there is a nice blogpost on this at grist

When the economy crashes, we run out of oil and nature disasters hit: we survive

While many of my post sound a bit pessimistic and critical, deep inside I am actually quite positive to the chances of humanity to survive. In the end I don't think a collapse of the economy or that we run out of oil will be such a disaster. I believe that how such a decent will go is largely determined of the social conditions. With a social cohesive environment, what often is called "social capital" we humans can manage the most difficult situation. That means a lot more than technology or economy for our resilience and our ability to cope with new situation.

One example is how Cuba managed the "special period" which happened when the Soviet Union collapsed and Cuba suddenly lost favourable trade conditions and access to cheap oil and things associated to that (like chemical fertilizers). They managed that remarkably well. They also manage hurricanes very well - Cuba is in the middle of the hurricane trail and still very few people ever die in hurricanes there. Compare that to Haiti, or even the USA (Having said this I am no great Cuba fan, it is an oppresive regime, and I am not that impressed by the organic farming, or the urban farms which many people point to as so great. But it is a function society, or at least has been) Regardless of how messy the situation in Japan looks today I am quite convinced that they will manage to survive the tsunami and that in a few months time things will work again - of course there is awful human suffering that will take very long to heal.

From Argentina you saw a lot of examples of what happened when their economy was in free fall some ten years ago.
Rosario, Argentina, embraced vegetable gardens as a way to pull through an economic crisis. It now leads the way among cities in the promotion of urban agriculture.
Providing the necessities for her family has always been a challenge for Vilma Cala, a single parent of four children in Rosario, Argentina. Her income from work as a domestic and the produce from a vegetable garden allowed her to put enough food on the table, but that was before the economic crisis that rocked the country in late 2001. The January 2002 devaluation drove the peso down to one-third of its value, and Cala, to a critical point. “I had to go to a soup kitchen and ask for food. It was terrible, having to depend on others. It really hurt, but I did it,” she says. “If you don’t have food to eat, you don’t have anything at all.” Now Cala tends a large garden in a field criss-crossed by inactive power lines. The garden produces enough for Cala to sell at a market that the municipality of Rosario created especially for urban farmers. She also belongs to a group of women that makes cosmetic products from natural ingredients such as nettle, aloe, and burdock, grown in their gardens. Cala’s earnings from these activities, combined with additional income earned by cleaning houses and gardening, has enabled her to regain some ground in providing for her family.
Read more

Also in Argentina, not only food production was reorganized, but also industrial production:
After the late 2001 financial and political meltdown in Argentina, thousands of companies were abandoned by their owners in a sea of debt. But some of them were taken over and reopened by their employees. Today, as the economy continues to grow, these worker-run factories are still going strong. There are now 205 "recovered" companies, with a total of 9,362 workers -- up from 161 companies with 6,900 workers in 2004, according to a study published in October.
read more
What is most important for us to prepare is to build strong social networks and support civil society and local governments. Those are the institutions that can bring us safely accross peak oil and financial melt-downs as well as tsunamies and earthquakes.

Njuice from Time magazine

...nuclear fission turns out to be an outlandishly expensive method of generating juice for our Xboxes.
writes the Time
In an earlier piece it wrote
If you want to understand why the U.S. hasn't built a nuclear reactor in three decades, the Vogtle power plant outside Atlanta is an excellent reminder of the insanity of nuclear economics. The plant's original cost estimate was less than $1 billion for four reactors. Its eventual price tag in 1989 was nearly $9 billion, for only two reactors. But now there's widespread chatter about a nuclear renaissance, so the Southern Co. is finally trying to build the other two reactors at Vogtle. The estimated cost: $14 billion. And you can be sure that number is way too low, because nuclear cost estimates are always way too low.