Friday, May 13, 2011

Military spending up 50% in ten years, US spends 43% of the world total

I knew it was bad, but I didn't know it was that bad!
The USA should simply be ashamed....
  • World military expenditure in 2010 is estimated to have reached $1.62 trillion in current dollars;
  • This represents a 1.3 per cent increase in real terms since 2009 and a 50 per cent increase since 2001;
  • This corresponds to 2.6 per cent of world gross domestic product (GDP), or approximately $236 for each person in the world;
  • The USA with its massive spending budget, is the principal determinant of the current world trend, and its military expenditure now accounts for just under half of the world total, at 43% of the world total;
"United States military spending remains exceptional worldwide, accounting for nearly 43 per cent of the global total. The US has also led the global surge in world military spending since 2001, increasing by 81 per cent compared to 32.5 per cent for the total for the 'rest of the world'. At an estimated 4.8% of GDP in 2010, US military spending represents the highest 'military burden' of all counties for whom SIPRI has data outside the Middle East."
Data from SIPRI

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Renewables: Dangerously positive news

Renewable energy could account for almost 80% of the world's energy supply within four decades - but only if governments pursue the policies needed to promote green power, according to a landmark report published on Monday, by the IPCC. It also concludes that - The technical potential of renewable energy technologies exceeds the current global energy demand by a considerable amount—globally and in respect of most regions of the world
This and similar messages are reported by the Guardian,
Renewable energy world
Huffington Post
International Herald Tribune

And well, it is quite obvious that renewable energy, in particular solar energy, can provide us with more energy than we use. But the report fails to discuss at what price. And here I don't refer only to costs in money, but even more harm on nature. The harm of hydropower dams is well known, biofuels production has the potential to compete with food production etc. And so does solar. A photovoltaic element has an energy efficiency of something like 10-15 percent, while crops only bind 1% or 2% of the energy. And we can put up solar panels all over the place. Solar panels are already put up on prime agriculture land.

I have read the IPCC summary, and think it is a bit strange that all articles and press releases are taking up this figure of 80% of the energy from renewables. That is the result of the most positive of 164 scenarios, while the least positive says 15%, which is just slightly more than today (12%). In addition the most positive scenario also assumes that total energy consumption will increase very little in forty years, while all indications are that it will increase a lot. "In the New Policies Scenario – the central scenario this year – world primary energy demand increases by 36% between 2008 and 2035, or 1.2% per year on average. This compares with 2% per year over the previous 27-year period." says IEA.


I am a great fan of solar energy and also of other renewable energy forms. But I also see their limitations. It makes me worried when their potential is "oversold". I do think it is realistic that they could contribute 80% of energy in 2050, but only provided that there is substantial savings on total energy use, a net reduction of energy use; that energy prices are at least doubled and that governments abolish perverse subsidies for fossil fuel and redirect investments in renewable.

The effects of reports as the one above can rather be negative; it makes people believe, again, that technical solutions will be found, which allows us to continue with business as usual. And that is the real danger. Very few will read and analyze the real content of reports like this.



Sunday, May 8, 2011

Capitalism: The right to extract wealth


When we buy stock we are not contributing capital: we are buying the right to extract wealth (Kelly 2001).

 

Capitalism doesn't require limited companies, but it is the institution that most clearly epitomizes capitalism. Take a small limited company. It has existed for ten years and its total revenue over ten years is in the range of 30 million dollars. The start up capital invested in stocks was 60,000 dollars. The shareholders have got small dividends over the year, just corresponding to a typical interest rate; they wanted to keep the profits in the company to allow for the rapid growth. Through accumulated profits, the company is now worth some 500,000 dollars, i.e. the value of the “investment” has increased eight times in ten years. This is nothing exceptional but all in all, it is a reflection of a moderately successful company. During the ten years of existence, some ten people have been working in the company. They have had a good salary; they even have been part of a profit sharing program. One now wonders why the ones who invested the original capital ten years earlier should be the owners of the whole company. Isn't it the fruits of the ten peoples' work that has made it to what it is today? The original capital, representing less than one man-year of work in value is now worth more than the 100 man-years of work dedicated to the company over the years. Funnily enough, we have come to accept this as the most natural thing. 
 
The stated purpose of limited companies is to supply their owners with profits. This is motivated with that the owners supply the capital that is needed to start and invest in the operations. That is also the reality when many companies start. The bulk of the trade in stocks is not about company start-ups, however, but it is stocks that are bought and sold in purely speculative purpose. In the period, 1900-1953 new stocks contributed less than five percent of the needed capital for US business. In the end of the 1990s only one percent of the value of the stock that was bought and sold reached the companies, the rest is only transfer between stockowners (Kelly2001). 

As the system is now, it is the stockowners that have the power over companies and the exclusive rights to profits. Not the total right actually, the other power centre in society, the state, has ascertained its share of the profit through company taxes, in almost all societies. One can also see this as a payment for the services companies get from society such as an educated work force, health system, legal system and protection. The employees, the clients, the local community or the environment, none of them have any right to a share in profits. Between 1987 and 1997, the stocks in Dow Jones index went up 300 percent. In the same period, real wages in USA dropped 7 percent. That can hardly be fair, reasonable or even efficient? As Schumpeter noted when companies are not managed by entrepreneurs but by professional managers, and owned by investors, the whole idea of ownership andentrepreneurship is destroyed (Schumpeter 1942).

Privatize profits and socialize losses

In a limited company the owner has unlimited rights to the profits of the company, but only limited responsibility for the losses. This is the essence of limited companies; two hundred years ago this didn’t exist. It is an innovation and a privilege extracted by the rich in the same way as the nobles saw to that their rights were enshrined in law. There were shareholding companies earlier, but the owners were personally responsible. In England, it became more straightforward to incorporate a joint stock company following the Joint Stock Companies Act 1844, although investors in such companies carried unlimited liability until the Limited Liability Act 1855. The emergence of limited companies is the first, and one of the more clear examples of how the wealthy class try to privatize gains and socialize losses, something that became very apparent during the financial crisis 2008-2009 where a trillion of dollars or more were used by governments just to prime the financial markets because they were not willing to take any risks; the same markets that claims the legitimacy of their mere existence with that they are needed to provide businesses with risk capital!


Friday, May 6, 2011

Why it isn't worse

Perhaps this says something about human nature. Google as of 6 May 2011 has 6,240,000 hits for "why it is worse" and only 2 (!) hits for "why it isn't worse" and eight for "why it is not worse".

(I was looking for a suitable quote to head a chapter with the title "why it isn't worse", in my book.)

The fish industry is ready to commit suicide at any time


"The world has passed "peak fish" and fishermen's nets will be hauling in ever diminishing loads"

Because we are land-living, our exploitation of the land has gone a lot further than the exploitation of oceans, but oceans are now rapidly exploited. Still, we use only eight percent of the biological production of the oceans, notwithstanding numerous fisheries have collapsed. On the temperate continental shelves, we use approximately 35 percent of the production. Our fisheries are targeting a few species, normally in the top of the food chain (cod, tuna, salmon). Global predatory fish biomass today is only about 10% of pre-industrial levels. At a first glance one might believe that it is quite safe to take the fish on the top of the chain, but that can also lead to major ecological changes. In addition, some fisheries have vast by-catches of other species, sometimes up to a third of the catch. The fishermen have to go deeper and deeper to get the fish and the fishing methods themselves destroy fish habitat, in particular bottom trawling. In the UK, landings per unit of fishing power reduced by 94%—17-fold—over the past 118 years. This implies an extraordinary decline in the availability of bottom-living fish and a profound reorganization of seabed ecosystems since the nineteenth century industrialization of fishing. (Vitousek and others 1997, Thurstan and others 2010, Economist 2009b).
Figure 1 The average depth of fishing 1950 to 2001



Source: MEA 2005

 The combination of increasing population, subsidies for oversized fishing fleets, too generous fishing quota, profit-seeking and new technologies has lead to massive overfishing. Most indications points to that we have already passed “peak-fish”, i.e. that global catches of fish are bound to decline (Zeller and others 2009). Between 1950 and 2005, commercial fish and shellfish landings in the United States increased by almost 90%, which could point to that there should be no worries. But since 1990, Alaskan waters have accounted for the bulk of U.S. commercial landings and Alaska is the only region where landings have increased since 1978. Landings have decreased between 1978 and 2005 in the West Coast and Hawaii, the Gulf of Mexico, and the North, Mid-, and South Atlantic (the H. John Heinz III Center 2008). Within the EU 88 percent of the fish stock is subject to over-fishing and 93 percent of the cod is caught before it is sexually mature, and will therefore never reproduce (Thurstan and others 2010, Economist 2009b). The world trade in fish has increased more than ten times in thirty years from 1976 to 2007 from US$8 billion dollars worth to over 90 billion (Ababouch 2009). Ironically, the fisheries are also subsidized to a large extent. In 2005, the total value added by global fisheries was estimated by the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP) to US$17 billion while subsidies amounted to US$27 billion (UNEP 2011).

The industry is ready to commit suicide at any time
The world has passed "peak fish" and fishermen's nets will be hauling in ever diminishing loads unless there's political action to stem the global tide of over fishing”, says Dr. Pauly, Director of the Fisheries Centre at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, Canada. "We don't need more science. This is a message that's different from many of my colleagues. Of course, we need to learn more about fish. But research is often publicly funded on the grounds that this is an alternative to other political action. We know enough to act to prevent the continued decimation of global fisheries." […]. Dr. Pauly is adamant that pulling back from a global fisheries collapse – one on par with the collapse of various regional fisheries, such as the Atlantic cod fishery off Canada's Newfoundland coast – requires recognizing what he describes as a deep divide between the fishing industry and those who eat fish. He argues that fisheries companies' actions show that they're primarily interested in maximizing short-term profit, with little or no regard for the long-term sustainability of fish stocks. "The industry is ready to commit suicide at any time," he says. (NSERC 2006)

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Turning water into wine - ooops, sorry, I meant dollars...


Each one of us needs a few litre of water for drinking and cooking. To that we need some 25-50 litres for hygiene and laundry. 3.4 billion people had to do with less than 50 litres per day 1991 and many with much less. I have seen women in Mozambique in the mid 1990s doing their laundry in potholes in the road after a rain. The average American used 350 litres per day and the Australian 570 litres, ironically, as Australia is the driest continent of all (Tansey and Worsley 1995). These figures don’t tell the full truth as countries that import water consuming raw materials are importing ‘embedded’ water from other places. For instance, direct consumption of water in the UK is only half of the quantity that has been used to produce things imported to the UK (BBC 2010). 

At the moment, humans are directly using some 10 percent of all fresh water. Indirect we use almost all of it. We certainly draw benefit from the rainfall on our forests, farms and rangelands. In the Middle East and North Africa 120 percent of all freshwater is used annually. That one can use more than 100 percent is explained by that there is a substantial use of fossil water, water left from earlier epochs, which is not recharged by rain in our times, and that groundwater is depleted quicker than it is re-charged. Agriculture scientists tend to believe that water use by human society, be it for households, industry or farming, of more than forty percent is problematic, while ecologists tend to think that this is already far too much.
The tapping of water from rivers and lakes for irrigation and for city and industrial use was doubled between 1960 and 2000. Seventy percent of all water use is for farming. The irrigated area has increased from 210 million hectares to 277 million hectares between 1979 and 2003 (MEA 2005). The drawing of water leads to rapidly falling ground water tables, in great parts of China and India with 1-3 meters per year (FAO 2003). In Australia, the situation is precarious and the government’s program Water for the Future allocates some AUD12.9 billion to secure water resources for all Australians, but also for the environment. Just in the Murray-Darling basin, AUD3.2 billion will be used to buy back water rights from farmers so that the water can be used for other purposes, mainly to maintain fragile and threatened ecosystems (Australian Government 2008).  

The word “rival” comes from Latin rivalis, meaning a person sharing the same water. Thirty-nine countries are currently getting most of its water from sources outside their territory (UNEP 2009). In many cases there are tensions between countries that share the same resources, and conflicts over water are likely to increase.  

Table countries with high dependency on water from outside
Region
Countries getting 50 %-
75 % of its water from outside
Countries getting more than 75 % of its water from the outside
Middle East and North Africa
Iraq, Israel, Syria
Bahrain, Egypt, Kuwait
East Asia and the Pacific
Kampuchea, Vietnam

Latin America and the Caribbean
Argentina, Bolivia, Paraguay, Uruguay

South Asia

Bangladesh, Pakistan
Africa south of Sahara
Benin, Chad, Congo, Eritrea, Gambia, Mozambique, Namibia, Somalia, Sudan
Botswana, Mauritanian, Niger
Eastern Europe and Central Asia
Azerbaijan, Croatia, Latvia Slovak republic, Ukraine Uzbekistan
Hungary, Moldova, Montenegro, Romania, Serbia, Turkmenistan
The OECD countries
Luxembourg
Netherlands
Source: UNEP 2009

Irrigation plays a big role for our food production. There is probably no single investment in farming that so clearly ‘pays off’ both economically and in increased productivity. In the end of 1990s, irrigated area represented a fifth of all agriculture area, but produced around two fifth of all crops and almost three fifths of all grain. FAO estimates that there is 402 million hectares of land in developing countries which could be irrigated of which only half of it is irrigated today. In Africa south of Sahara, only four percent of the farmland is irrigated and the area has only increased with four percent the last forty years (World Bank 2007). Approximately, two thirds of all rivers in the world are used for irrigation or hydro-electricity; in the USA, only 2 percent of the rivers flow freely. Great rivers like the Colorado, the Nile and the Ganges have almost no water left when the reach the sea. Great lakes such as Lake Chad and the Aral Sea have shrunk tremendously. In the case of the Aral Sea, this affected both the fisheries and the whole climate around the lake with sand storms and disease following (Vitousek 1997). There are several limitations to the expansion of irrigation, however, one is simply access to water; the other one is the loss of biodiversity from the land that can be irrigated, which today mostly are swamps or other wetlands. If wetlands are drained they will normally also be converted from carbon sinks to carbon emitters. In areas of high evaporation, salinization can be an additional problem. So there are reasons to believe that irrigation will not expand as much as theoretically possible. There are also many opportunities to improve water stewardship in existing irrigation schemes or to introduce small-scale technologies such as rainwater harvesting[1] in farming systems.

Be paid to waste

Pricing of water in most countries represent an actual subsidy of farming over other sectors. In the end of last century, the global water subsidies were estimated to 33 billion dollars, a fact that certainly reduces the incentive of farmers to save water (Worldwatch Institute 2000). Only the Netherlands and Austria of twelve OECD-countries priced water at any rate that could be called commercial[2]. Household and industries paid between US$0.5 and US$3 per cubic meter while farmers paid a few cents or even fractions of a cent. Now, irrigation water and drinking water are two different qualities of water, but the difference in price doesn’t represent that quality difference. Even in a dry country like Australia, households paid almost hundred times as much for their water than did farmers (OECD 2001).
That water subsidies are neither sustainable for the environment nor for financial reasons is shown again and again. In the 1970s, Saudi Arabia supported massive expansion of grain production based on subsidized irrigation. It was, by and large, very successful. In the 1990s, it became clear that it wasn’t sustainable. In some areas, ground water table dropped 5 meters per year and some farmers were drilling at 1000 meters to reach water. In response to this production of wheat was reduced from 4.5 million tons 1992 to 1.8 million tons 1993 and the production of barley dropped from 2.2 million tons to just 100,000 tons by year 2002. In 2002 the ministry of agriculture announced that it would cease feed production altogether because of its negative effect on water resources. (USDA 2002). In Santa Fe, New Mexico, the local government recently began requiring home builders to retrofit six existing houses to offset the added water use for each new house built (Ruddiman 2005). Las Vegans are paid to rip out their lawns and opt for (chic) desert landscaping (The Economist 2011a).
While a human need a few litre of water to drink, at least thousand times as much water is used for production of our food (Kijne and others 2009). The water need for foods vary tremendously and they vary for the same product under different conditions. From Australia, the following quantity of water is reported to be needed to produce a kg of a product.
1 kg of wheat, 715-750 litre of water
1 kg of corn, 540-630 litre of water
1 kg soy, 1,650-2,200 litre of water
1 kg rice, 1,550 litre of water
1 kg beef, 50,000-100,000 litre of water
1 kg wool, 170,000 litre of water[3]
(Meyer 1997)
Other figures are reported elsewhere; from the UK, a kg of beef is said to embed 15,000 litres of water (BBC 2010). The fact that a certain food needs a lot of water is as little as with energy an absolute reason to avoid a certain food. Nevertheless, a discussion on embedded water, or virtual water as it is also called, is obviously more and more relevant the more scarce water resources are seen to be. One weakness in water discussions and the concept of embedded water is that it equals all sorts of water. There is ‘blue’ water – water in rivers and lakes; there is ‘green’ water – water in rainfall and in the soil; there is ‘grey’ water – i.e. waste water and there is also fossil water in aquifers. Concentrated water in a lake is a more useful resource than rain[4]. All in all global water supply is strained and locally water is already now a very limiting factor for development. There are many ways to improve water management and the efficiency of water use, ranging from simple solutions such as rainwater harvesting to high-tech recirculation of irrigation water in green houses. To reduce wasteful consumption, subsidies should be abolished and perhaps water use itself should have a price tag.

Turning water into property and money

“The fluid nature of water has always made it difficult to turn into private property” writes Radkau (2008), but then what increasingly are turned into property is water rights. The oil tycoon and investor T Boone Pickens has bought up water rights of the Ogallala aquifer in the USA for some US$100 million and expects to sell water for some US$165 million per year once the thirst of Dallas is big enough (Bloomberg 2008). Not surprisingly, this has triggered public outrage, regulatory responses and lawsuits. Parallel to private encroachment on water rights. Maintaining the water catchment areas is rapidly turned into a commodity by means of "watershed service payments". In 2008 there were some 300 schemes with payments of a total of  US$ 10 billion (Ecosystem Market Place 2010). 
(Extract from Garden Earth).  

In additon, the waterworks have increasingly been privatized last decades
Currently there is a rush to privatize water services around the world. The World Bank and International Monetary Fund (IMF) are pushing for the privatization of water services by European and U.S.-based companies. They are pushing privatization through stipulations in trade agreements and loan conditions to developing countries. These privatization programs started in the early 1990’s and have since emerged in India, Bolivia, Chile, Argentina, Nigeria, Mexico, Malaysia, Australia, and the Philippines, to name a few. In Chile, the World Bank imposed a loan condition to guarantee a 33 percent profit margin to the French company Suez Lyonnaise des Eaux while the company insisted on a margin of 35 percent.
writes Water is life, which also have a lot of useful resources about water.  A complication in the discussion is that public utilities in many developing countries have grossly mismanaged their task and failed to deliver, similar as many of the public telecom and elecrticity utilities:

The truth is that many of the world’s poorest people are, perversely, already paying three to 10 times the global average price for water, due to the failure of public utilities to provide any access at all, says Caroline Boin, a director at London think tank the International Policy Network. In Kibera, a sprawling Nairobi slum—the biggest in Africa—the only way to get water is through a network of porters that provide water to 500,000 people a day, hauling it in canisters on their backs or by donkey. By some estimates, more than half the population of cities in the developing world get their water this way.
writes McLeans Canada
 
Another aspect is that water pricing, or lack of pricing has not promoted a sustainable use, and lack of pricing also means that faucets can stand running for day. I have often been struck by this phenomenon. In Sweden which is blessed with water resources (and where the public sector runs the utilities) you very rarely hear the constantly dripping faucet or the noise from a constantly flowing WC. But in many poor countries that is a very common situation. Water is a badly managed commons. I don't think privatisation is the cure, and I don't think we should cling to corrupt utilities. Where the public sector isn't doing its job properly, I think the local communities can take care of it instead. They will most likely also ensure better and wiser use. But, in addition, we need to set some kind of "price" on water itself to encourage responsible use.

some eartlier posts: Why Free is the wrong price for water


[1]       Rainwater harvesting is the collection of rainwater to provide drinking water, water for livestock or water for irrigation.
[2]       Which still in this case only means that the costs for extraction and distribution is recovered, not that a price has been allocated to water itself.
[3]       Notably the figures for meat and wool also include water that is falling as rain on the grazing areas and the feed producing areas for the animals. Most of the grazing areas are far too dry to be used for any farming.
[4]       A bit similar like discussions about energy where one can’t equal heat energy with electricity.

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

Which values do we support with our slogans?

If we want to build a better world, we can't use arguments which are supporting 
behaviors or values which were part of the problem to begin with. 

Just the other day, I wrote the post Talking the Walk. And now I just read the report Common Cause - the Case for working with Cultural Values published by Oxfam in partnership with; Climate Outreach Information Network (COIN), Campaign to Protect Rural England (CPRE), Friends of the Earth (FOE), Oxfam GB, and WWF-UK.

It speaks about the same things, but in slightly different way. It is about how the language we use can appeal to values that either support to cause or works against it. In the efforts to be more appealing, to "sell" the message. Environmental and social movements have learned how to adapt the message to the different target groups. So business people get the story of the triple win (good for business, good for environment, good for the people) and are told that it is profitable to care for the planet or for the people. But the underlying assumption in this is that it is only if it indeed is profitable that you will and should have to.

I have myself been part of so many studies and so many campaign where it has been discussed, "how do we make this appealing to policy makers, how do we make it appealing to business, or to the Jones in the street". The same goes for the much hyped Green Economy.
read more at UNEP, WorldWatch Institute,
The new green economy
Fueling our future (with friends like that, you don't need enemies!!!!)

I wrote myself about the Green Economy in two posts
Jackson's Cinderella Economy and
Green Economy a win-win-win?

Green economy is simply an oxymoron as long as the economy is ruled by profit-making. And to appeal to profit making as the thing to fix it is, ultimately, just aggravating the problems.

I have always had a gut feeling against that kind of reasoning, and slowly I start to understand why. This is again the old story about "The ends justify the means". But it doesn't and it never did.

Saturday, April 30, 2011

Talking the walk


There are inherent values expressed in our language. I will never forget Phuntso from Bhutan, who at the final evaluation of a one month training said that he had found the training very useful, but that he took exception of that we referred to some animals as meat, we called them "beef cattle", which is what you do call cattle destined for the slaughter-house in Sweden. Our ideas and the language we use for technology, ecology and economy, even for people (who are "workers" or "capitalists" or "consumers") are part of our cultural narrative, similar to the religious categories (sin, guilt, hell, heaven) of previous cultures. We often smile over other cultures' myths and fetishes, but we fail to see that the holy car is as laughable as the sacred cow, the statues of the Easter Islands or the temples of Maya. In my writing I have used expressions like "social capital", "ecosystem services", "externalities". They all take the norm from the capitalist world view. So called economic externalities can also be called "destruction" or even "theft", because that is what it amounts to. By speaking about "biomass" we point at the use of life as a raw material for further processing. Not only that, the use of the word "biomass" makes algae, a rose, a cow and a forest interchangeable and see them primarily as raw materials in our mills. 
 
Money is like an alphabet with only one sign says Alf Hornborg (2010). That is the reason for why you can't communicate any meaning with money, anything more nuanced than a call to consume, i.e. to use up resources. In the market society the only way to assign a value to anything is to sell it (or as we seen in some examples about ecosystem services, to trade the guarantee that it will not be traded, i.e. exploited), which means that things that are outside the market circulation almost by definition has no value.

Our use of money as the sole ruler of value and the submission of our society to "economics" make us believe that market transactions are voluntary, that we are enabled by the market instead of dependent, and that those transaction are equal and fair. How we discuss "efficiency" or "productivity" and "technology" has strong biases, clearly visible in agriculture, where the systems that waste most, pollutes most and use much external energy are those that are "modern", "efficient" and "productive". The function of technology[1] to put other peoples' resources in the service of the already wealthy, and to constantly increase the gap is obscured by our myths about "progress". Governments speak about their citizens as clients or customers and NGOs use market logic to achieve their goals (even "sell their message", their magazines are closed down because they are not “profitable”) and churches compete for souls in the market place with simplistic TV spots much in the same way as political parties do. In changing the world we also need to change the language use. We need to build new narratives, new tales, new heroes and new myths.





[1]       This is obviously not the only function, but one that is largely overlooked.

Thursday, April 28, 2011

The business plan of the factory is to produce externalities


To a very large extent, many of our industrial technologies are about producing "externalities". The industrial capitalist model extracts resources in distant places (destroying other peoples' nature and possibly livelihoods), it has workers do something with them and pay them only part of the added value, the cost of pollution is carried by the local communities, the cost of health care is footed by society, the cost of schooling the workers is covered by society etc. The products are sold at a profit and the waste is someone else's problem. Our natural and social "commons" are resource pools and dumping grounds for the factory. Those that are most successful in externalising their costs are the most successful. "The rationale of machine technology is to (locally) save and liberate time and space, but (crucially) at the expense of time and space consumed elsewhere in the social system" as summarized by Alf Hornborg (2006). When one realise this, one see that what economists are calling "externalities" as if they were some kind of mistake in the process, are part and parcel of the business plans that are behind factories. Of course, there are tools and machines that are producing very few externalities or where those externalities are very small. By and large, however, competition drives industries into increasing externalities. The most apparent example is re-location of factories, to the emerging economies, where salaries are lower and regulations laxer. Many more trends in modern manufacturing can be viewed with that perspective. There is always a counter-movement from society to pressurise industries to take care of those externalities, as they are indeed damaging.

Hornborg (2009) shows how the unequal exchange underlying machine technology can be exposed by measuring the net flows of biophysical resources such as energy, matter, embodied land (ecological footprints), or embodied labour. The mechanical ‘power’ of the machine is to a large extent also an expression of the economic and ideological ‘power’ through which it is sustained. Ultimately, what keeps our machines running are global terms of trade, where the poor get a raw deal. Like with so many other discussions it is hard to discern cause and effect. Is it technology, the machine, as such that creates this imbalance in power, or is the imbalance in power that skews the application of technology into favouring the powerful? I think that they are mutually reinforcing, like so many other issues. In the market place, it is clearly technologies - and organizational forms - that tilts the terms of trade in your favour that will survive. Technology has created the illusion that economic processes can "produce" resources; that we through technological and economic transformation of raw materials into consumer goods can make more resources available; for the price of a particular consumer good, we can buy more material than were used for the production of the good. This is also reflected in the extraction of added value from labour. The value (price) of a good is higher than the work embedded in it, after deduction of other costs, which means that the capitalist can buy more work. These are also the mechanism by which capitalism, technology and economic growth are intrinsically intertwined, and one more reasons for why sustainable capitalism is an oxymoron.


Hornborg, Alf 2006, Footprints in the cotton fields: The Industrial Revolution as time-space appropriation and environmental load displacement, Ecological Economics, Volume 59 Issue: 1, Pages: 74-81
Hornborg, Alf 2009, Zero-Sum World Challenges in Conceptualizing Environmental Load Displacement and Ecologically Unequal Exchange in the World-System, International Journal of Comparative Sociology Vol 50(3–4): 237–262

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Welcome to Antropocene and the anthropogenic Biomes



While most ecologists classify the biomes (nature types or ecosystems) of the world largely as if they were not touched by humans, the truth is that humans now influence most parts of the world, even to the extent that some scientists speak about the Antropocene as a geological era; that we actually change both the geology and climate. Ellis and Ramankutty (2008) identify eighteen anthropogenic biomes and only three biomes that could be considered ”wildlands”, most of them barren, permafrost or sparsely forested. The wildlands represents around 22 percent of the terrestrial land, but only 11 percent of the net primary production (the photosynthesis) because they are cold or dry, or both. All other nature type have been so heavily influenced by humans that they can be called man-made landscapes. Of course, even in those landscapes there are patches of land that is less influenced and even in a field, there are weeds and wild life, but they are all there under conditions created by us; ”human systems with natural ecosystems embedded within then”. It is assessed that we control at least one third of the all terrestrial primary production (i.e. the biological production emerging from the photosynthesis). Rangelands are with this classification the most common landscapes, covering nearly one third of the ice-free lands. Due to arid conditions, the primary production is low, only 15 % of the worlds total and only 5% of the population lives in those landscapes (Ellis and Ramankutty 2008). The value of marginal land is changing. In the past livestock occupied vast territories because there was no possible – or profitable alternative use. It might actually be better to have wild animals roam those plains – as they did long before we tamed our animal companions.

Area, population and primary production of the world

Area (%)
Net Primary Production (%)
Population (billion)
Dense settlements
1.11%
1.4%
2.57
Villages
5.9%
7.7%
2.56
Croplands
20.8%
32%
0.93
Rangelands
30.4%
15.5%
0.28
Forests
19.4%
32.8%
0.04
Wildlands
22.5%
10.7%
0
Source: adapted from Ellis and Ramankutty 2008.

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

The tragedy of the tragedy of commons


(what is tragic with this forest?)

The expression “tragedy of the commons” (Hardin 1968) was coined by the ecologist Garret Hardin (1915-2003) to describe that common resources need to be protected and monitored to be protected from over-exploitation. Many, in particular neo-liberals have used his article, or at least the catchy phrase to argue that common resources should be privatised because that would mean that they will be taken care of; sustainability would be guaranteed through the profit interest of the individual. It has also been used against common management or public management of resources. Hardin himself clarified in a later article 2003 that what is needed is that the commons are managed: "A 'managed commons' describes either socialism or the privatism of free enterprise. Either one may work; either one may fail: 'The devil is in the details.' But with an unmanaged commons, you can forget about the devil: As overuse of resources reduces carrying capacity, ruin is inevitable." He also stated that:

The more the population exceeds the carrying capacity of the environment, the more freedoms must be given up. As cities grow, the freedom to park is restricted by the number of parking meters or fee-charging garages. Traffic is rigidly controlled. On the global scale, nations are abandoning not only the freedom of the seas, but the freedom of the atmosphere, which acts as a common sink for aerial garbage. Yet to come are many other restrictions as the world's population continues to grow. (Hardin 2003)[1]

Very seldom do we hear those that babble about the tragedy of the commons quote this statement.

Privatization of commons played a big role for the development of capitalism in England. It is worth noting that there is no indication of that those commons, before they were privatized, represented any tragedy, i.e. that they were mismanaged in any way. They were common in order to protect them from over-use rather than the opposite (Montgomery 2007). On the Solomon Islands, the white beech is a rare tree essential for constructions of canoes. When someone knows they will need a new canoe in the future, they mark a young tree to inform the others of its future use, and still ask the chief for permission before finally cutting it (Satoyama 2010). The same is reported from many other places: ”well-organized village communities were frequently in a better position to care for the common forest in keeping with their needs than money-hungry lords who wished to fill their coffers with the forest and who often did not even know the woods they were supposedly protecting”. It was precisely the division of the commons that was often followed by the cutting of the forest (Radkau 2008). Our society institutions are also a kind of commons, created by ourselves. Last decades have experienced a wide-spread battle over how to manage resources like schools, hospitals, utilities, postal service and water works just to mention a few.

Experiences of how to manage common resources point in different directions and we should not jump into conclusions how they should be managed in order not to be destroyed. There are other options than privatization and state control; many common resources, probably most, have been managed by local communities, and it is rather recent that they have been either privatised or taken over by the state. Elinor Ostrom, 2009 Nobel Laureate in economy, has shown how cooperation in the management of common resources is the rule rather than an exception (Ostrom 2009). What is of critical importance is that the users have real say in the arrangements. This is hardly anything new; Kropotkin said the same almost 150 years earlier. For sure there will still be no guarantee that the management will be perfect, people can act egoistically or foolishly both as individual owners and members of a community. The difference is that in a community, the majority must act egoistically and foolishly for it to dominate.


(More extracts from Garden Earth)



[1] My references to Hardin here should not be seen as an endorsement of his ethics regarding how to behave in an overstretched world, some of which I find questionable to say the least.

Monday, April 25, 2011

carbon projects drives land grabbing and GMOs?

Carbon credits rarely deliver money to projects and communities on the ground. Out of a total carbon market volume of $144 billion in 2010, only 3,370 million (0.2%) was for project-based transactions, with only a very small proportion of that likely to reach the community level. Most of the money stays in the global North, even though projects themselves are in the South. Those that benefit most from carbon trading are financial speculators such as J.P.Morgan, Goldman Sachs and Merryl Lynch, who buy and sell carbon credits like they do any other internationally tradable commodity.
Says a briefing from the Gaia Foundation. They claim that there private companies will draw all benefits from carbon offsetting projects. I am inclined to agree with them that there are big risks for that, and that ultimately, carbon credits, mitigation banks, payment for environmental services (TEBB) represent a giant leap towards privatization of our common nature resources. I have written about it many times. 
Ecosystems: Invaluable and worthless

I can also recommend a paper by Sian Sullivan:
The environmentality of ‘Earth Incorporated’: on contemporary primitive accumulation and the financialisation of environmental conservation

Having said that, I don't really agree with some other analysis in their briefing. Two other points are that 1) it is very hard to measure the real offsets in soils, 2) GMO crops and land-grabbing are likely to be strong features in carbon offset projects. There is a certain merit in both point, but rather limited in my view. There is no indication that carbon offset farm projects will use more GMOs than food production. And the same land grabbing are explained by increased food prices, meat production, production of export crops and bio fuel. I don't defend land grabbing, but it is essentially a function of inequality and power relations regardless of the purpose for which land will be used. Huge land grabbing has taken place in most parts of the world in stages.  Just look at the Americas, earlier colonial land grabbing and even massive land grabbing of forests some hundred and fifty years ago in my native Sweden - or even the classic enclosures in England some five hundred years ago. With increased pressure on land, we will see more in the future, if local communities power over their resources are not asserted. I do realize that it is very hard to measure actual carbon sequestration in soils, but don't think it is a valid argument against agriculture carbon sequestration projects. It is difficult to measure most effect from farming, because it relies on local eco systems and because it is carried out by half a billion people, each one doing a bit differently. But with that logic you could also not make statements on effects of farming on environment, biodiversity, the nitrogen cycle or almost anything else as they are all site specific and hard to measure.

Gaia contradicts itself somewhat, when calling for "the use of agro-ecological farming systems to minimise agricultural GHG emissions, and to restore soil carbon. These approaches also provide numerous “multi-functionality” benefits for adaptation, ecosystems, human health, equitable access to resources, and long-term food security." This is a clear example on where it is really hard to measure carbon offset, compared to large-scale carbon offset programs. Don't misunderstand me, I support the use of organic and agro-ecological farming, but if you argue about its benefits for carbon sequestration, people will compare those with other farming systems. 
"Agriculture, with its intensive use of fossil fuels, synthetic agro-chemicals, machinery, transport and intensive livestock rearing, is clearly a significant contributor to climate change. But done properly, the right kind of agriculture can also be a major part of the climate solution.", says Gaia. I couldn't agree more.

Sunday, April 24, 2011

To save nature – with no nature


My latest posting was about that local food production is not always the best, and now this one is about that sometimes use of non-renewable resources can "save" on renewable resources. And before that I spoke for more nuances in how we look upon meat production. Am I leaving the environmentalist camp? Well, I am not so keen on being in any "camp" at all, but I certainly prefer the environmentalist camp over the other.  Having said that, I think it is best for us that we have a nuanced view of reality. The dogmas make it harder to find solutions.

The use of non-renewable resources has followed man since she became man, first in the form of stone for tools. There has been a dramatic shift of our production and consumption away from renewable sources to non-renewable sources, fossil fuel and minerals lately. By and large, this is a negative development as these resources, by definition, are not renewable, and will sooner or later run out. Sometimes the use of a mineral can lead to a substantially eased pressure on a renewable resource, however. One such example is the production of potash. Potash is a raw material used from the dawn of history in bleaching textiles, making glass, and in making soap. It is today also the basis for potash fertilizers and various food additives. In the 19th century, it became an important export product for countries like Canada and Sweden. Forest was cut down and put into big heaps and burnt, just to be able to extract the ash, which was the raw material for potash. Large tracts of forest were cut down in order to produce potash. The relationship was 1:1000, i.e. thousand ton of wood was needed to produce one ton of potash. As early as 1767, potash from wood ashes was exported from Canada, and exports of potash and pearl ash (potash and lime) reached 43,958 barrels in 1865. The industry declined in the late 19th century when large-scale production of potash from mineral salts was established in Germany (Ostlund 2009, Wikipedia 2011a). The example of potash shows how a wasteful use of natural, renewable resources could be replaced by a rather harmless use of mineral, non-renewable resources. There is also a movement between different materials. Asphalt is used instead of cobble stone, concrete instead of wood or stone, iron replace bronze and so forth. Substitution of raw materials is an ongoing process and human ingenuity is great if the price is high enough. This is however mainly true for minerals and other raw materials, but not to a very large extent for ecosystem services. Our ability to substitute for ecosystem services is very small, both because they are so complex and hardly visible and even more because they are for free – there are simply no incentives to “save” on them. 

Why local food production is stupid in Dubai

"We don’t have water here, it’s a stupid idea to farm without water.” says Nils El Accad, CEO of Dubai-based Organic Foods and Café. He continues:“Most farmers rely upon desalinated water, which means the carbon footprint of food grown using it is much higher than if you air freight it in,” read the rest. 

I did a job for the ministry of agriculture in the UAE some ten years ago, about the development of organic agriculture in UAE. My conclusion was quite the same: Date palms, sheep and camels are the traditional food produced in these very dry areas, and they can be produced sustainably. But all the vegetables, the strawberries and other food are better produced where there is more water around. Alternatively they can use waste water for irrigation of the food crops - now they use it for golf courses and lawns - equally ridiculous things in a desert.  For using waste water they need to change their consumption patterns and use less harmful stuff. 

Neighbouring Saudi Arabia has also come to similar conclusions, as I write about in Garden Earth: 
In the 1970s, Saudi Arabia supported massive expansion of grain production based on subsidized irrigation. It was, by and large, very successful. In the 1990s, it became clear that it wasn’t sustainable. In some areas, ground water table dropped 5 meters per year and some farmers were drilling at 1000 meters to reach water. In response to this production of wheat was reduced from 4.5 million tons 1992 to 1.8 million tons 1993 and the production of barley dropped from 2.2 million tons to just 100,000 tons by year 2002. In 2002 the ministry of agriculture announced that it would cease feed production altogether because of its negative effect on water resources.
Local food production is in most cases a good idea, but there are many situations where some trade is also justifiable also from an "ecological" perspective. Alpine farms specialize in animal production, making cheese etc. They have bought grain for centuries, which is actually a better idea than plowing steep mountains. The same patter can be seen where farms in mountain areas in Italy and Greece grow olives and grapes, and buy grain from plains. A too fundamentalist approach to local self-sufficiency would in those cases be more damaging.