Tuesday, March 15, 2011

our energy debt

Jan Willem Storm van Leeuwen explains one reason for why nuclear power is so popular:
One of the unique properties of the nuclear energy system is the possibility it offers to man to postpone material and energy investments to the future. The massive amounts of radioactive materials, including the clean-up and dismantling waste, have to be isolated from the biosphere forever, in order to keep the countries with nuclear power and their neighbour countries habitable for man.
His extensive report has some very interesting graphs:

This one shows the energy pay-back for nuclear power, i.e. how long it has to operate in order to "pay" for its total energy use. Because the Uranium concentration of the ore is absolutely critical in this context it is drawn as a function of that. As you can see, when the concentration moves towards 0.03-0.02% U3O8 the whole thing is rather pointless, notwithstanding all other problems.


Also regarding CO2 emissions the results are not very positive. Lifetime emissions of CO2 from nuclear power are approaching those of a gas-fired electricity generator, and also here, if ore grades are leaner the emissions increase dramatically.

These picture and his report reconfirms the view that nuclear power is only profitable because of exploitation of:
current society, that subsidize nuclear power tremendously all from footing all the research, the risk, the security and the infrastructure needed
other places for uranium production and the people living in those places
other resources for the construction and management of the stations and the people living in the places where those resources are extracted
future generations

In a way, nuclear power is the the highlight of our corrupt society, and just an extrapolation of how society deals with environment and the rights of future generation.

I can also recommend this posting by Alexis Rowell

Climate; doing the things right or doing the right thing?

The climate issue has, for rather good reasons, taken alarmist proportions. We are given advise how to eat, travel, farm, perhaps even love climate-friendly. “Climate friendly” has in a short time become synonymous with environmentally friendly. It is good that GHG emissions finally, after being ignored for more than thirty years (I have books published in the sixties, e.g. by Murray Bookchin and Hans Palmstierna that pointed out the risks of climate change, with surprising accuracy), are getting attention. However, there are many other pressing environmental, and social issues, and there is a risk that they simply get lost and that decisions are made solely to address climate change with potentially serious adverse effects on other important things. Big biofuel schemes can threaten valuables biotopes; the perception that meat is not climate friendly can reduce grazing cattle in Europe with serious effects on landscape and biodiversity; meat consumption is geared towards (grain-fed) chicken instead of beef; that eating prefab foods from the supermarket is more energy efficient than cooking at home (which it is to many's surprise) may lead to further industrialization of our food; chemical pesticides and GMOs are promoted as alternatives to mechanical cultivation; the camp fires of scouts should be banned and we increase our distance to nature a bit more; nuclear power is promoted as a saviour. The list is long, and get longer by the day.

I believe that it would be much better to focus on energy, and the transformation of our society to a society that uses considerable less external energy. That is much more concrete and it tackles the problem of peak oil. It will have a direct measurable effect on climate change as well as on many other environmental problems, as energy use together with mindless consumption and profit are the three main drivers for destruction of nature - and society as well for that matter.

Humans and energy - the long view

In times of energy-anxiety it can be good to take the long view:

An extra stomach

Some hundred thousand years ago humans started to use fire. It was a first defining moment for humanity to use external energy for its purposes. Fire gave heat, but it also meant that we could eat things that we couldn’t eat before. Even for those things we could eat, the conversion of them to energy in our body was substantially improved. To heat food makes it softer and more easy to digest, even if the food doesn’t contain more calories through cooking, it uses less energy for digestion and more of the energy in the food can be absorbed. Some claim that cooking was a prerequisite for developing the human brain, which uses between 20 and 25% of all energy in food (the Economist 2009a). One could see it like fire is an external assistance to our metabolism. A cubic meter of firewood represents some 1 MWh, i.e. more or less a humans annual energy consumption in food. To make a serious camp fire to cook a deer you need some 50 litres of wood, i.e. 50 kWh. This corresponds to 15 people's daily energy consumption in the form of food.

Already the introduction of fire meant that we humans took substantial energy sources under our command. And still today, hundred thousand years later, firewood or charcoal (made from firewood) for cooking represents a very substantial parts of poor peoples’ energy use. As mentioned earlier, fire also played a very important part in the development of our tools, from its use to break rocks, to melting ores and burning pottery. In the emerging farming, fire was used for land clearing and for getting rid of waste and pests. Pastures were maintained and rejuvenated through regular burning. This is still a common, and necessary, practice. One might say that more than anything, possibly with the exception of the spoken language, fire was that made us human.

Oxen and mules

Introduction of drought animals some 6000 years ago was another form of conquering more power for human needs. Still today, there are some 400 million drought animals in the world and fifty percent of all agriculture land is managed with the help of drought animals. They are some 300 million cattle, including buffaloes, and 80 million horses, donkeys and mules (IFRTD 2009). The power of the animals varies from some 200 watt for a donkey up to 650 watt for a camel. They also endure in varying degrees, four hours for a donkey and up to ten hours for a horse (cattle certainly endure, but they simply spend so much time to eat and ruminate the food that they can’t work so long hours). This means that the daily energy output can be somewhere between 1 and 6 kWh (FAO 2000) to compare with the human’s 0.5-1 kWh. Drought animals thus meant a substantial extension of the power that could be put into our service. However, natural and biological conditions limit the use of them and their efficiency. In most agriculture situations they can only be used, or are only needed, in a rather short period of the year. Most importantly, they could expand the land brought into cultivation by increasing the land cultivated especially in the countries with very seasonal farming (the temperate climates or those with marked dry seasons). It is stated that a settler family with drought animals could farm more land than a whole Native American village could (Cunfer 2005). For trade, animals resulted in even bigger advantages; one human can easily lead five animals that all of them carry heavier loads than a human could.

Drought animals have to eat, so their use will be limited when land is scarce. They are easily kept in large numbers in areas where there is plenty of pasture that grows year round. In temperate climates, where the grass doesn’t grow in the winter, substantial areas of farm land had to be set aside for growing the feed for the animals. In slash and burn (swiddening) cultivation systems there is little space for drought animals, as the roots and the rubble in those fields make working with pulled tools difficult. In addition, the fire does a lot of the work in the first place, so the need for animal power is much less. In Africa south of Sahara, it was only in modern time drought animals were brought into use. A study from Mali and Senegal shows that drought animals represent 90 percent of the mechanical energy in the farms. They were introduced in Senegal, Guinea and Mali in the end of the 1920s, and the main effect was that the proportion of land that was cultivated increased from 30 percent to 40 percent in Senegal and from 40 percent to 70 percent in Mali (Faye and Faye 2009).

Wind and Water

Sail ships are shown on an Egyptian vase that is 5,500 years old. Wind is a good example of how it is not enough to know an energy sources to be able to use it. Anybody walking against a storm can feel the power, it is first when we know how to master and target it that it becomes useful. In its simplest form, wind energy was used, and is still used today for winnowing, separating the grain from the chaff by means of throwing up the grain in the air. The wind will then take the lighter chaff, twigs and other impurities with it. It took a long time before water and wind power became important for the production as such. Wind power was used mainly for milling and pumping and water wheels ran pumps, mills, and later in sawmills and trip hammers.

The most important use of these energy forms was for communication. The streaming water in rivers were used for transportation of various goods, but could of natural causes only be used one way. The real revolution was the introduction of sailing. Sailing allowed human expansion and increased trade tremendously; it also led to the distinct advantage for coastal areas for economic development, a pattern that holds still today.

Charcoal and wood

Wood has many uses. It has been the totally dominating fuel. It has been used for shipbuilding and housing and in all kinds of crafts and production from pottery to mining. Everywhere wood was needed and used. The energy intensity in wood can increase by making charcoal, that simplifies transport and storage and gives conditions for a more efficient combustion and higher temperatures[1], the latter was very important for the development of metallurgy. Most civilizations would simply have been impossible without forest and some of them collapsed because of collapsing forests. The deforestation of the Mediterranean is one such example. In Europe, the forest resources were approaching a collapse in the 19th century. Wood was used for more and more purposes and trade expanded rapidly. Similarly, as oil price hikes threaten to destabilize the world economy of today, scarcity of wood threatened the society 200 years ago. This changed when profitable uses of fossil fuel, in particular mineral coal, were introduced (Högselius 2008). Even a sparsely populated and forest rich country like Sweden had widespread deforestation in its mining areas in particular. In more densely populated areas with iron works such as in Luxembourg the wood price increased with a factor of 24 from 1611 to 1790 and in German Hunsrück wood prices increased almost hundred times in less than 150 years. This was also the background to the early forest conservation efforts in Germany.

Table 4: Wood price in Hunsrück 1655 to 1791

Year

Index

1655

100

1705

243

1752

2,857

1791

9,514

Source: Moreau de Gerbehaye 2002

A similar situation was apparent in Japan and China. Japan was largely deforested and the government took harsh measures to protect forests and to plant new forest. In some regions of Japan, saws were banned to protect the forest. One of the reason for Chinese decline can very well be a combination of soil erosion and deforestation (which often go hand in hand and feed each other). In 1949, Japan had restored forest so that they covered 68 percent of the land, while China had 8 percent (Radkau 2008).

Coal, natural gas and oil

The use of fossil fuels has increased 800 times since 1750, and has increased 12 times during the 20th century (Hall and others 2003). Fossil fuels represent some 80 percent of all energy supply today. There is no principle difference between coal, natural gas and oil, even if the practical usage differs a bit. They are all three created by photosynthesis and geological processes. Of the total stocks of fossil fuels, coal is dominating with some 70 percent and coal represents today 26 percent of the global energy supply. Coal is mined and used in all continents. We have already discussed the importance of coal for the early industries. Up to the middle of 20th century, mineral coal was the completely dominating fossil fuel and also gas and to some extent a liquid fuel was produced out of coal.

Petroleum (Oil) has been known for thousands of years and was used as a fuel from the mid 1800s. The comparative advantage of oil over coal is that it is more energy dense (50 % more energy per weight units) and that it is liquid and therefore easily regulated and fed into an engine. Compared to biomass, oil has an energy content per kg that is four times higher (Helmfrid and Haden 2006). Its primary use is for the transport sector where the petroleum derived gas, kerosene and diesel runs all kinds of vehicles, planes and ships. Ninety-five percent of the transport energy is from oil and today oil represents 34 percent of the energy supply.

Natural gas is cleaner than coal and oil, at its combustion, carbon dioxide, steam and nitrous gases are the main effluents. For this reason, gas is the most rapidly increasing energy source and represents today some 20 percent of the use (IEA 2008). The usage is limited by that natural gas is bulky and it has to be compressed for transportation and most uses.



[1] The total energy content of wood doesn’t increase by coaling, on the contrary opposite some energy is lost in the coaling process.


This is an extract from my book Garden Earth . I wil soon post something about energy today

You find selected other extracts from Garden Earth here

Monday, March 14, 2011

There will be no nuclear power without oil

In times of peak-oil, climate change and a resurgence of nuclear power it is good to take big picture perspective on developments and not discuss details in safety, or if the oil peak has already occurred or will occur twenty years ahead - the point is that it is a fact.
I write in Garden Earth
Harnessing energy and the use of this energy in various technical applications is one of the most characteristic and defining human activities. Technology is not neutral and one kind of technology requires or fit in a certain society. And not only that; certain technology will only be developed if another technology is in places. Therefore, different technologies and societies hang together in technological complexes and it is not possible to change or say no to one component and keep the rest. Because of all these interactions, one can speak about a thing like the “nuclear power society”. That society pre-supposes a highly educated corps of engineers (which in turns presupposes higher education and technical schools); reliable entrepreneurs (little corruption); uranium mining; access to global technology; intelligence agencies (checking the reliability of staff); bugging of telephones; surveillance systems capable of operating for millennia and a number of special, technologies essential for the operation of nuclear reactors. A nuclear power society also needs oil for many purposes, for building of the plants to driving emergency pumps and generators to transporting uranium and fuel. Therefore is nuclear power society not an alternative to oil but an extension of the oil society.

Thinking about Ghadaffi, I should add, that a nuclear society pre-supposes political stability over centuries - and can we find any country that has had that?

Beyond Sustainability

A few days ago, I decided to drop the reference to sustainability in the heading of my blog. I simply can't identify myself anymore with a political mantra that has lost almost all meaning. In agriculture, the field where I am professionally involved, for ten years already ALL governments and the whole agri-business from Monsanto over Unilever to Wal-mart and Tesco pay lip service to "sustainable agriculture", and the more it has been embraced the less meaning it has today. It all started with the Bruntland Commissions report, Our Common Future which tried to convince political leaders that there is no contradiction between economnic growth, social development and care for the planet. I write in Garden Earth:

“What is needed now is a new era of economic growth - growth that is forceful and at the same time socially and environmentally sustainable.” writes Gro Harlem Bruntland in the foreword to the report. We learn that it is possible to combine economic growth with social and environmental development, not only that; the message is actually that we need more economic growth to deal with these challenges. And a free market is best situated to deal with the issues. Many ecological activists, and even more social activists, question this. The environmentalist see economic growth as a main driver for continued excessive exploitation of nature, and social activists doubt that the free market can handle the increasing gaps in the world. Both question how more of the same could cure the problems they caused.

Economic growth always trumps social development or environment protection. So from now on I will speak about: Beyond Sustainability. I did check the net for the term and see that others are already using it, some in a similar way as I do, some in the same way as PB speaks about Beyond Petroleum, i.e. just more green-washing

Sunday, March 13, 2011

Jackson's Cinderella economy

I just finished reading Tim Jacksons book Prosperity without Growth, one of rather many (including my own Garden Earth) recent books challenging conventional wisdom about growth.

The book makes an easy read, and it is well written and structured. It has a large listing of references but the text is not littered with tables or charts. It deals with both ecological, social and psychological challenges in a discourse about what it is the creates prosperity, or flourishing as Jackson also calls it. It shows, convincingly, that growth isn't, or shouldn't be a prerequisite for a good life on earth. On the contrary growth, and the thereby linked constant quest for more makes us less satisfied (Jackson is careful to point out that material growth is still needed in the developing world). He shows in many ways that the notion of de-coupling, i.e. that we can have economic (GDP) growth and reduced environmental impact is a myth. E.g. even if we shift from manufacturing and "things", the way we spend our leisure time now account for as much as 25 percent of our carbon footprint. He sees one part of the economy as a candidate for prosperity creation without detrimental effects on the environment, this part he calls the Cinderella economy: social and community based enterprises, farmers' markets, gardening sport clubs and libraries to mention a few.
"People often achieve a greater sense of well-being and fulfillment, both as producers and consumers of these activities, than they ever do from the time -poor, materialistic, supermarket economy in which most of our lives are spent. But in formal terms these activities - let's call them ecological enterprises - barely count. They represent a kind of Cinderella economy that sits neglected at the margins of consumer society".
Like many others he calls for changing the macro-economics and proposes variables to reflect energy and resource dependency, ecosystem services and stocks of natural capital. He makes many recommendations for a transition to a sustainable economy grouped under
1. Establishing the limits (Resource and emission caps; Fiscal reform)
2. Fixing the economic model (developing the macro-economics; investing in jobs; revising national accounts (GDP))
3. Changing the social logic (Working hours; tackling inequality; measuring flourishing; dismantle consumerism and strengthening social capital).

He criticizes, in my view rightfully, Green Economy initiatives, not for being bad but for not being enough, and for keeping people within the Growth paradigm

He asks the question if all what he proposes amount to "the end of capitalism". His discussion here doesn't impress as much as the rest of the book. He first says that the answer depends on how one define capitalism and reduces this (referring to Baumol) to whether the means of production lies in private hands rather than with the state . In my view a fatally flawed definition, a definition that implies that also most pre-industrial societies were capitalist with the exception of a few centralised empires such as Incas and Pharaohs. With this definition he goes ahead to reduce the question about end of capitalism to be about private or state ownership of means of production. He concludes, rightly, that between pure private and pure state there is a wide spectrum of possibilities. He does mention other options, such as employee ownership, but only as an argument for why the clear distinctions between capitalism and socialism (now, suddenly, "end of capitalism" would have to mean "socialism") is rather meaningless. In the end his answer to the question is that it is an irrelevant queestion: "Is it still capitalism? Does it really matter?"

I can understand that Jackson doesn't want to get stuck in the "capitalism" discussion. To challenge one of the most sacred cows of capitalism is a mouthful already, and when one attack capitalism people close their ears. In this way his book reminds me Jonathon Porrits Capitalism-as if the world matters, another book that shows well how unsustainable current development and that all the incentives are wrong. Unfortunately however, the proposals Jackson (as well as those of Porrit, Hawken and Lovins) makes for how to solve things in the economic sphere, their feasibility is totally dependent on the incentives and economic drivers that rule and those are largely a result of the capitalist society we have. We can't put them on the head and keep the system. Or to borrow the words of Murray Bookchin

Capitalism not only validates pre-capitalist notions of the domination of nature – it turns plunder of nature into society's law of life. To quibble with this kind of system about its values, to frighten it with visions about the consequences of growth, is to quarrel with its very metabolism. One might more easily persuade a green plant to desist from photosynthesis than to ask the bourgeois economy to desist from capital accumulation. (Toward an Ecological Society)
Still, I recommend Tim Jackson's book.

What gives value to an eco label

ISEAL, recently came out with an interesting report, the ISEAL 100 survey. In it we can read the views of 100 "thought-leaders" on environmental and social standards. One chart that struck me was this.

So the view of the users (i.e. companies) of these systems is that most important to create trust in a standard is: verification processes, including accreditation and third-party certification (55%);
a standard document at just the right level (science-based, comprehensive, practical) (38%);
a credible multi-stakeholder standard-setting process that has the support from all relevant parties – NGOs, producers, companies (35%),
a transparent governance model (32%);
and being able to show impacts (11%).

I found this discouraging and it strengthen my view that the people involved in the "sustainability industry" (folks that are environment, CSR managers, employees of certification and standardization bodies, consultants like myself, international NGO or international organisations) are losing the grip of what is important, the impact. The "worst" case is the ISO "management" standards (ISO 9000, ISO 14000 and ISO 22000), but their thinking has spread all through the systems. In some cases this is just a result of more or less intentional green-washing, but in most cases, I believe it is a result of application of the same kind of industrial, standardized and simpleton thinking that brought us the problems which were to be solved.

Into Eternity

I believe the timing of the movie Into Eternity was almost as "good" as the timing of "the China Syndrome" which was released on March 16, 1979, 12 days before the Three Mile Island nuclear accident


Nuclear power is scary from many perspectives. In my view the scariest of them all is that you need a high-tech, high-energy, high-control society - not governed by maniacs like Colonel G - for the technology and we have no idea if humanity can - or even want to - maintain such a society for the times to come.

Tuesday, March 8, 2011

The wealth Pyramid - a sign of poverty


One can draw a lot of different conclusions from a pyramid like that
Credit Suisse, the one making the graph concludes.
It for instance points out that the global wealth currently held by 4.4 billion adults has increased by 72 percent since 2000, to reach 195 trillion dollars. Driven by robust economic expansion in the emerging markets, the Credit Suisse Research Institute estimates that global wealth will grow 60 percent to 314 trillion dollars by 2015. The middle segment of the global wealth pyramid is composed of one billion individuals who are located in the fastest-growing economies of the world and hold one-sixth or 32 trillion dollars of global wealth. In total, almost 60 percent or 587 million individuals in the middle segment of the wealth pyramid are located in Asia Pacific. China stands out as the third-largest wealth generator in the world, behind only the US and Japan, and is 35 percent ahead of the wealthiest European country. Read more
And of course, it is their business to care for the ones that have money to spend, i.e. their clients or prospective clients. My concern is more the 3 billion at the bottom and the fact that they will be there also 2015. The fact that gaps are increasing is simply not acceptable and it is also not sustainable or tenable in more normal language (this sustainable word is rapidly taking the lead in being the most used, overused and abused word in English language) It should worry also the rich, because sooner or later this will explode, and I doubt the poor will show much mercy with those that have lived on their backs.

Read also
Growing inequality, between people, between countries, between region, between urban and rural.
Who gave you your property?

We are the world - or?

Monday, March 7, 2011

Power to the commons

Something amazing has just happened. For the first time ever in Canada, perhaps in North America, property can be owned by a community – not just by a government, a corporation, a private individual or even a group of specific individuals. The Gabriola Commons has created an agreement which allows a piece of land to be owned by all of us, as the people who are residents of Gabriola Island in British Columbia. Gabriola owns The Commons despite not having municipal status - and the British Columbia government has officially approved the notion.
read more...

I find this very encouraging. Changing ownership is most likely one of the most powerful drivers to change society.

Beyond Petroleum - a joke

BP President Carl-Henric Svanberg made a blitz visit to Malmö today where oil spills were on the agenda.He sad he was sorry for the big blow-out in the Mexican Gulf last year, but confirmed that BP will continue with deep sea drilling of oil.

He said:
We are not doing this by choice. We are doing it out of necessity. We estimate that by 203o the world will be consuming some 40 percent more energy than today. And the world will continue to be largely dependent on fossil fuel. (recording from the Swedish Radio P1)


I look for some more information at the BP website and find the 2030 energy outlook report
There we can read:

At the global level, the most fundamental relationship in energy economics remains robust – more people with more income means that the production and consumption of energy will rise....Energy consumption per capita to 2030 is likely to grow at about the same rate as in 1970- 90 (0.7% p.a.).....The fuel mix changes relatively slowly, due to long asset lifetimes, but gas and non-fossil fuels gain share at the expense of coal and oil.....Strong growth in non-OECD energy consumption, especially of coal, translates into continued growth of global CO2 emissions. The growth of global CO2 emissions from energy averages 1.2% p.a over the next twenty years (compared to 1.9% p.a. 1990-2010), leaving emissions in 2030 27% higher than today.

The web site says that "The outlook highlights the central role markets and well-designed policy can play to meet the dual challenge of solving the energy needs of billions of people who aspire to better lifestyles, and doing so in a way that is sustainable and secure. "

I think the whole thing just shows what a gap there is between what needs to be done and what BP is planning for. And that the re-branding of BP from British Petroleum to Beyond Petroleum was just green-washing.

Friday, March 4, 2011

Victor Ananias


In just learned that Victor Ananias passed away.

I visited his place in Küçükkuyu in 2008 on my long bicycle trip. He welcomed me by frying falalfel (see picture). I spent a few days, left my bicycle there and came back two month later to continue my trip. I had the opportunity to give a hand with rolling the ecological roof of the new center that was under construction. Victor was very enthusiastic and had lots of good ideas and initiatives. He was an organic champion, knowledgeable, a good person and a good friend. There is some text and pictures on:
http://gunru.blogg.se/2008/december/the-bugday-centre-in-kucukkuyu-12-14-december.html
and
http://gunru.blogg.se/2009/february/mandelblommor-i-sno.html (mixed Swedish and English)

"From village farmers to agricultural policymakers to consumers, his efforts have affected thousands of people. Victor’s dream has undeniably changed the face of Turkey and infused its ecological movement with a powerful momentum in the right direction. "
says a nice article from 2007.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

If you don't have cash you don't get to eat

Says Raj Patal, in this video about the emergence of global food markets and their effects, with an emphasis on India.



I make the same case about global food markets in Garden Earth and in frequent blog postings. In particular it is important to realise how new food markets are and that they are constructed by power relations.

Monday, February 28, 2011

False Choices: Cap and Trade Vs. Carbon Tax

I came across and interesting article by James Barnard Quiligan in Cosmos
In searching for answers, society is trapped in a false dichotomy: we believe that only markets and governments are capable of providing solutions for climate change, even though these institutions were never designed to internalize the costs of negative externalities like carbon emissions. There is another way to solve collective problems of this scale and jurisdiction. The emerging framework of the commons brings the monoculture of the Market State— the modern economic and governmental superstructure—into sharp focus and provides the analytical tools and predictive power to penetrate the deep dichotomies of its operations and policies. The commons illustrate, for example, how the major policy responses to global heating—cap and trade (via the private sector) and carbon taxes (via the public sector)— are more about the ideological debate on how much government regulation should be permitted in the market economy than about climate change itself.

This coincides well with my views expressed in Garden Earth:
There are others in the boat than the state and the capital

In politics, there is a traditional divide between those that think that a function shall be taken care of by the market and those that believe it should be by the state. Somewhat simplified the former are liberals and the latter socialists. One can look upon both markets and the state as social institutions to regulate relationship between people and distribution of property and products. Which institution one like the most depends perhaps on ones own situation, how it is organized and which context it is in. The same person that is very sceptical to market solutions is perhaps perfectly comfortable with her relationship to the organic farmer and found it deplorable that the government determined that organic chicken were not allowed to go out during the bird-flu scare in 2006. And the person who is against government control still applause government take-over of bankrupt banks or car-makers. One can also look at the roots of the capitalism and the state and see both of them as parasites from different epochs. The state is with this perspective a remnant of the war-lords and kings that established a Mafia style of protection. The market, as it has developed now, is an institution for capitalist exploitation. By forcing bigger and bigger parts of life into the market, capitalism can extract wealth from most parts of life and not only from the simple distribution of goods. Through political struggle, people have to some extent taken over control of the state, but that is not the case for the market. Despite all the hype about the market as a democratic institution, it is a place of very imbalanced relationships.
In form, they are very different. We, as citizens, have very little access to the state, our role is to pay taxes to finance it and regularly vote who shall rule it and therefore rule us. We sometimes interact with the state through civil action, direct contact with a politician, participation in a demonstration or writing a letter to the editor in a newspaper or a complaint (or more rarely praise) on a web site. In the markets, we on the other hand are constantly participating and in theory, we are equal with everybody else in the same market, as long as we have money to pay at least. The market can be seen as a giant social decentralized network. With this perspective, the difference between the state and the market is smaller, and it becomes even less when the state or the public sector has adopted the market terminology, management patterns and even acts as an “owner” or as a “client” to a lot of its own services which are actually taken care of by private companies. The problem with the market in this perspective is mainly that it that it favours those that are already rich and those that have better information and that those differences tend to increase over time rather than the opposite. The other problem with markets in their current shape is that they pitch people against each other through competition, something that in turn is bad for society.

State take-over of markets has in most cases been disastrous and market take-over of the state is almost as bad. Obviously, a certain balance is the best. But here we also need to look beyond markets and the state. The question is not only if a certain function shall be executed by the state or the market. By concentrating the debate around the market or the state, we tend to lose sight of the other possibilities. There are many other possibilities as we discussed earlier. There are completely voluntary associations formed to take care of a certain need, such as the need for youth to meet and dance or do sports; or to take care of a certain resource, such as cutting a meadow by scythe yearly or keeping an old foot path open. There are municipalities where the citizens in a very direct way organize most of their support needs. There are personal-cooperative day care centres, schools run by parents, homes for elderly owned and controlled by the elderly themselves; road cooperatives and irrigation communities. In Sweden there are 26,000 housing cooperatives owning in total 800,000 apartments (Bo Bättre 2009). Our voluntary organization to accomplish certain objective is very old, much older than both markets and state and is not at all limited to not for profit purposes. There is no indication that such arrangements would have been inefficient. Capitalism has, however, often worked against them simply because they limit the business opportunities and central governments have sometimes also made life difficult, or even prohibited them because they undermined the tax base and made people more independent from the state.


Did you pay Angeles Duran today?

After billions of years the sun finally has an owner - a woman from the Spanish region of Galicia said she has registered the star at a local notary public as her property. Angeles Duran, 49, told the online edition of El Mundo she took the step in September after reading about an American who had registered himself as the owner of the moon and several planets. Read more.

I simply love this kind of news. It says so much about our world, and I don't think I have to comment it further.

Monday, February 21, 2011

Green Economy a win-win-win?

Green agriculture is capable of nourishing a growing and more demanding world population
at higher nutritional levels out to 2050. An increase from today’s 2,800 Kcal availability per person per day to around 3,200 Kcal by 2050 is possible with the use of green agricultural practices and technologies. It is possible to gain significant nutritional improvements from increased quantity and diversity of food (especially non-cereal) products. During the transition to green agriculture, food production in high-input industrial farming may experience a modest decline while triggering positive responses in the more traditional systems, which account for nearly 70 per cent of global agricultural production. Public, private and civil initiatives for food security and social equity will be needed for an efficient transition at farm level and to assure the sufficient quality nutrition for all during this period.

This is written in the Chapter on agriculture in UNEP's report on "Green Economy" which was launched today (I had the opportunity to comment on the draft). UNEP says that the report challenges the myth of a trade off between environmental investments and economic growth and instead points to a current "gross misallocation of capital". The report sees a Green Economy as not only relevant to more developed economies but as a key catalyst for growth and poverty eradication in developing ones too, where in some cases close to 90 per cent of the GDP of the poor is linked to nature or natural capital such as forests and freshwaters.

Well, I wished UNEP is right. But I have my serious doubts. I don't have any doubts about the feasibility of Green Agriculture (Organic), renewable energy etc. but I do have doubts that this major conversion of society is doable without changing the underlying drivers and mechanisms. Those brought us here in the first place. The report partly acknowledge this and suggest extensive financial incentives:
Agriculture’s environmentally damaging externalities could be reduced by imposing taxes on fossil-fuel inputs and pesticide and herbicide use; and establishing penalties for air emissions and water pollution caused by harmful farming practices. Alternatively, tax exemptions for investments in bio-control integrated pest management products; and incentives that value
the multi-functional uses of agricultural land have proven effective in improving the after tax revenues for farmers that practice sustainable land management....Payments for environmental services (PES) can further incentivize efforts to green the agriculture sector.

It is theoretically possible. I have myself studied how such a transition would look like in Moldova, Ukraine and Armenia (for UNEP, report to be published soon). However, we have to realise that these massive interventions in agriculture will amount to very detailed regulations and a maze of taxes, incentives, regulations etc. Do we want that? And why do we need that? Mainly because the underlying economic drivers (essentially the capitalist market economy) have created the situation we have. I believe time is now ripe to question those drivers instead of tweaking with the incentive structure.

Saturday, February 19, 2011

What's in a name?

I posted my little piece on "call it non-organic" also on Linked-in, where it kicked off an intensive debate. Well, the reason for why we speak or write in general is to get some reaction, isn't it? So I am very happy for that.

Friday, February 11, 2011

Consumer labelling, the next trend?

Perhaps this is the new trend: Consumers label the products and not the producers....

This is an initiative of the Organic Consumer Association in the USA.
they describe it as follows:

Do-It-Yourself GMO Labels: Show Grocers How to Label Their GMO and Factory Farmed Foods!

This month, the Millions Against Monsanto Truth-in-Labeling Campaign will start taking matters into our own hands. We're sticking "Oh No! Is It GMO?" labels on non-organic foods likely to contain GMOs as well as non-organic meat, dairy, and eggs coming from animals raised in CAFOs, (Confined Animal Feeding Operations), where they are force-fed GM grains.

Read more

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

call it non-organic

Words are important. Language is important. What we call something tend to have more meanings than just the technical identification. If we call somebody a terrorist or a freedom fighter makes a difference. If we say someone was shot, killed or murdered also makes a difference. Why is nobody defending "capitalism" but we all love "the market economy" when, essentially people mean the same thing with the two words (the answer is that "capitalism" implies that someone is making a buck from this system and it ain't me!). But also for less dramatic things our language is full of values.

In farming we often speak about conventional and organic as opposed pairs. With this use of words organic comes out as a bit strange, perhaps appealing to the more radical people, but far from being normal. One step is to call conventional farming for "industrial" or "chemical" farming. That sounds decisively negative, but perhaps a bit provocative-which sometimes is good and sometimes is counterproductive. My latest take on it is to call it "non-organic". In that way, organic becomes the norm, the normal and non-organic becomes something strange. In addition, it has a negation, which is never good - people like positive things. I hope that the organic community will go for this in the future.

Sunday, February 6, 2011

Nice ice

One thing I like with Sweden is that we have so many useful signs to find your way. Here they even put up signs for the skaters to find their way to Uppsala and Stockholm - and it is more than 70 km skating between the places...






Wednesday, February 2, 2011

John Stansfields Garden - I don't dig and I don't do weeds

I had the pleasure of touring the Pacific on an FAO job together with John and Hiva from Niue. We had a nice time.


Tuesday, February 1, 2011

At last(?) Yuckmeat

"Synthetic food" has been in the pipe for many years, at least since the Apollo project (the moon landings). I heard a speach by agriculture scientist Jaochim von Braun last September where he predicted that it landless food production would be a big trend the coming 50 years.

Now there is a new product in the pipe: In a small laboratory on an upper floor of the basic science building at the Medical University of South Carolina, Vladimir Mironov, M.D., Ph.D., has been working for a decade to grow meat. read article. Since quite long there have been efforts to make animal feed in labs.
"Microbial biomass is produced commercially as single cell protein (SCP) for human food or animal feed and as viable yeast cells to be used in the baking industry. The industrial production of bakers’ yeast started in the early 1900s and yeast biomass was used as human food in Germany during the First World War. However, the development of large-scale processes for the production of microbial biomass as a source of commercial protein began in earnest in the late 1960s. Several of the processes investigated did not come to fruition owing to political and economic problems but the establishment of the ICI Pruteen process for the production of bacterial SCP for animal feed was a milestone in the development of the fermentation industry. This process utilized continuous culture on an enormous scale (1500 m3) and is an excellent example of the application of good engineering to the design of a microbiological process. However, the economics of the production of SCP as animal feed were marginal, which eventually led to the discontinuation of the Pruteen process." (Wikipedia)
The product "Quorn" has become quite successful as a vegetarian "meat". There are many issues around these synthetic foods. With genetic engineering we certainly will see more of it in the future. There are reasons to be caustios about the health effect of eating the stuff. Some of them will probably show to be harmful, some might be perfectly safe. we will realize this by the same crude process of trial and error that humans have used all along...and sometimes, "shit happens".

What I find a bit disturbing is that few people seem to realise that also so called lab-food needs a feedstock. Energy can't be created out of nothing, and even less can proteins etc. be that. All synthetic foods grown that I heard of are using biological materials as feed stock. It's not like you can take oil, nitrogen from the air, phosphorus from the soil crust and shake it and you have high quality food. I am sure that there are technical possibilities to do something like that, with massive investments (the guy in South Carolina wants a billion dollars to develop his process). But nature already does it. And there are few signs that our labs can make it better. To grow corn for feedstock for artificial food or for the production of chicken is in a way not a big difference. Chicken production, as it looks like in many parts of the world, is already landless production, a kind of feed converter factory. And it is obvious that you can do a similar things with fungi or bacteria. It is not obvious, however, that the process will be much more efficient. Perhaps more appealing for vegans. I would be ironical that vegans would lead the process for a further distance between the human and the food she eats.
In the end, I don't want to eat Quorn or any other lab-made foods.



Monday, January 31, 2011

Struggle between paradigms

In Burundi land is so scarce (or some people don't have land?) that they grow all the way to the edge of the roads (this is the main road from Bujumbura to Kigali)

In my recent trip to Burundi and Rwanda, I saw some examples of the rather schizophrenic policies that are ruling agriculture. In Rwanda the government is vigorously promoting chemical fertilizers trough different schemes in different crops. For some crops farmers get vouchers that give them fertilizers for free. In the case of coffee, "for free" means that the government
tax the coffee exports. This means that the government let the farmer get a lower price and deprive them from taking their own decisions how to farm. It also means that those that chose not to use any fertilizer, e.g. organic farmers are subsidizing the non-organic farmers. This is very far from good politics.

The same country also have some policies very favorable for organic farming, e.g. the program One-cow-per household, and they have recently initiated a large, World Bank funded (!), project for hillside irrigation, where all the farms will be organically managed. Our consultancy company Grolink, at this very moment, conducts training of 20 horticulture cooperatives in organic farming for the Rwanda Horticulture Development Authority, and we also consult two coffee cooperatives as well as a tea company. The minister of agriculture, Agnes Kalibata, has spoken up in favour of organic farming many times.

Burundi and Rwanda are intensively farmed and densely populated. Their proportion agriculture land is around three quarter of all land, an exceptional high figure.
The land is also mostly steep and therefore prone to erosion.
Erosion in Burundi

It is assessed that in Rwanda 1.4 million tons of soils is lost each year and with that soil 41,210 tons of nitrogen, 280n tons of phosphorus and 3,055 tons of potassium. In some areas losses can reach a staggering more than 500 tons per hectare and year! The losses of nutrient due to erosion is bigger than the total amount supplied with chemical fertilizers. It is calculated that the erosion corresponds to a decline in capacity to feed 40,000 persons per year (data from the Strategic Plan for the Transformation of Agriculture in Rwanda - Phase II, February 2009).

If anybody doubts the influence of government and social stability on farming, crossing the border between Burundi and Rwanda is a telling story. In Rwanda terracing is much more developed (and in many cases the kinds of terracing is clearly a result from larger initiatives rather than individual farmers) There is also much more forest, especially on the top and ridges of the hills, where erosion starts. Notably Rwanda has been politically stable since the genocide, while Burundi only has had peace a few years.
Terraced landscape in Rwanda

Rwanda and Burundi are certainly not alone in having contradictory agriculture policies. The EUs CAP is just a jumble of contradictions. And the US promotes GMOs while it gives some money to organic farming, Farmers' market. Contradictory policies are rather the rule in agriculture.

Sunday, January 30, 2011

In search of a publisher

My book, Garden Earth, has now progressed to a stage where I am ready to present it for a publisher, so I am seeking a publisher in UK, USA, Australia, India or...An idea of the content is presented here. The book has been well received in Sweden. Some reviews are presented here. It has also got support for "excellent and high-quality literature" from the Swedish Council of Culture. If you have a good idea about publisher, send me a message: gunnar at grolink.se

Why not call it by its proper name: theft.

I believe most people have understood that most property is based on privilege of different sorts, but not that most of it derives from theft or violence. How did that piece of land that is sold today originally come into hands of a private person?
well there are some possible sources. But by and large they almost all come to that the government gave it away or sold it to a private person. Because it is government that defines property, it all derives from government, or the state.

To convert land from public or communal stewardship to private ownership is just the first, but an essential step to make land into a tradeable commodity, and part of the transformation of society into a market society. Speaking of the "primitive nature" of indigenous peoples, US Commissioner of Indian Affairs, T. Hartley Crawford stated that, unless some system is marked out by which there shall be a separate allotment of land to each individual […] you will look in vain for any general casting off of savagism. Common property and civilization cannot co-exist.(Kinney 1975).

It is interesting to note that a professor in the stronghold for "free market" economics acknowledge this. "Land, natural resources, and government contracts and licenses are the predominant sources of the wealth of our billionaries, and all of these factors come from the governement" says Ragharam Rajan, economist in Chicago (IHT 26 Jan 2011, the superrich pull ever farther away), referring to billionaires of India. This is the case of the billionaires of China and Russia as well, and was certainly true also for the robber barons and the railroad magnates of the 19th last century.

And no doubt, enormous wealth and therefore property is generated by the American wars in Iraq and Afganistan. And what about all the banks and financial institutions that have been bailed out by government. Using "our" money to cover "their" losses. That amounts to nothing but theft.

"Property is theft" ( La propriété, c'est le vol) already the French anarchist Proudhon in 1840.

Having said that, obviously I don't mean that all people that have property are thieves, I have property myself as a starters and I don't consider myself a thief. And there are reasonable arguments in favour of why a person should "own" his or her own dwelling, clothes and perhaps the means of production (which is rarely the case today, where the means of production mostly are owned by a few). Farmers need to own - or at least have long term control over - the land they farm (well it can be communally own as well as most land was before stolen by the government or private interests). The defense for private property mostly takes it start in nice description of how private entrepreneurs create wealth both for themselves and other people by setting up a small enterprise. Also this can be discussed, but it should be noted that this image of how private property is mainly used is showing a very small part of what private property is about in most parts of the world.

There is some essential truth in what Rousseau wrote:
“The first person who, having fenced off a plot of ground, took it into his head to say this is mine and found people simple enough to believe him, was the true founder of civil society [Rousseau certainly was not referring to what we today call civil society, but rather to what we call civilization]. What crimes, wars, murders, what miseries and horrors would the human race have been spared by someone who, uprooting the stakes or filling in the ditch, had shouted to his fellow-men: Beware of listening to this impostor; you are lost if you forget that the fruits belong to all and the earth to no one” (Rousseau 1964).

Friday, January 28, 2011

Sowing the seeds





Raised bed of typical Gako design, and a tyre garden

I have been on a mission for IFOAM to Burundi, Rwanda and Tanzania, and seen many interesting things and met a lot of good people. I uploaded some pictures that you can look at.

One of the places that impress me is the Gako organic farming training centre in Rwanda. I have visited it before, in 2007 and the manager, Richard Francis Munyerango (to the right in the picture above), participated in a Grolink training afterwards. The place is so impressive from many sides. It has trained some 60,000 people in organic farming in ten years, including a lot of demobilized soldiers. It has also trained a lot of women groups (read more). It is also very well maintained, the gardens are a pure delight. Slowly by slowly the place is expanding with new buildings, a shop, more land etc. Richard seems to be a very skilled manager as well and his business model has proven to work. The centre is financed through the "selling" of courses to organization and is thus not dependent on core funding for its existance. If there were more places like this.


Patricia Wangong'u checking the pineapples

Thursday, December 30, 2010

Good news from China

"For years, humans have tried to conquer nature, but in doing so, they themselves became conquered. They lost their connection with the earth. They destroyed the land they were tilling. In Buddhist belief, there are no pesticides, no bad insects, no good ones. There is only imbalance in the world. We must restore that balance." Says Han, a new farmer in China.

As a reaction to the last decades of breakneck growth and environmental destruction, similarly as what happened in western countries in the sixties and seventies perhaps, there is a counter reaction in China with an increased interest in organic food. Also, a number of people, mainly rich, take a step further and go back to the land, start farming. This all according to an article in the Washington Post. Read more. At least some good news at the end of 2010.

(oh my, it feels like the much feared Y2K (if you are below 25 I am sure you have no idea what Y2K means, and I almost forgot it myself, but came across it the other day, and smiled a bit) was just a few years ago. What happened with those 10 years. Someone stole them?).

Even if most people expect nothing good from China and the other BRICs when it comes to the environment, I believe the future of humanity rests in the hands of those rapidly growing economies, for the better and the worse. In Garden Earth, I write:

There will be winners and losers among countries, regions, organizations and individuals. The people that are privileged today, like myself, will see their privileges diminish. But to lose privileges mustn't be a disaster, it can also be liberating in the same way as the abolition of apartheid in South Africa didn't only liberate the blacks but also the whites from an undignified relationship. If I might venture a guess, it is that we will find the winners in the middle income countries. This may sound surprising as they are the ones that also are well known for break-neck growth and environmental degradation. But they are not yet stuck in the high energy society, and in any case, it doesn't offer them the same prospects as it did the high income countries as returns, both economic and energetic on the use of more energy are diminishing. They have, hopefully, learned something from our mistakes ad they can challenge the high income countries politically and economically. There is a middle class that can be engaged in a political change project. They also have a very big part of the world's population, so their choice is to some extent the choice of humanity. In Europe and the USA, environmentalists have for decades used a rhetorical question: “what will happen of the Chinese adopts western lifestyles and consumption patterns?” Now, this question is no longer a rhetorical question. It is reality; soon but it will not be answered by western environmentalists but by the Chinese themselves; because whatever the global impact is, the impact in China itself will be even greater. In 2006, there were 16 million electrical bicycles in China, in 2010 their numbers were probably 120[1] million (NYT 2010c). They are for sure no ideal and not unproblematic from an environmental perspective, they spread led from batteries and they need coal-generated electricity (ADB 2009). Nevertheless, they are clearly favourable compared to cars, and the infrastructure needs is the same as for the benign snail-bicycle, and they represent just one of many examples of how they can avoid the mistakes of high-income countries. China is also the number one producer of solar technology. Countries, such as the USA, which whole society is stuck in and fed by high-energy consumption and a world order where it has profited from the weakness of others will have difficulties to find new ways. The poorest countries, on their hand, will be stuck in the wish to be rich and they will also lack social, manufactured and human capital to make a comprehensive and fundamental change.


[1] In the Swedish edition of the book, I wrote: in 2009 there are probably 50 million...




Monday, December 20, 2010

Advise for Christmas


Don't buy too much stuff this Christmas!
Why?
Well, if you haven't understood that yet, you have some homework to do....

says anti-Santa Gunnar, here with the Sydney opera as a hat.

Tuesday, December 7, 2010

A model for fair trade.

"It takes a village to raise a child"

That is a Tongan Proverb. I am currently on a job for the FAO for the development of the organic sector in the Pacific. I am now in Fiji after visiting Solomon Islands and Tonga.
Similarly as in Samoa, which I visited earlier this year, and in Bhutan there is an interesting culture. While it is an old culture it might also have seeds for the future. The proverb is stressing the need for community. The Westerns view, or at least the view that has penetrated Western culture lately is based on an extreme individualism. According to Time magazine for this week, it has grown worse. Anyway, traditional cultures pay a lot more attention to family and not only that, at least in some cultures the local communities are also seen as essential, which is exactly what is expressed in that proverb. Ultimately we are a social being and not individuals. It is the social organization of humans that made us to what we were. If we had been "individuals" throughout history, we would hardly been different than any other animal. It is actually only the most primitive animals that are acting as individuals.
Society IS part of humanity.

An interesting feature in Tonga is how Tongans "trade" with the Tongan communities abroad, in particular in New Zealand. While someone in Sweden might send a box of Swedish stuff to some emigrated relatives the first years, Tongan families (extended families) fill a CONTAINER with taro, tapioca, coco nuts and whatever they have and send off to relatives in New Zealand. And some time later perhaps a container goes in the other direction with some building materials and household appliances. Or perhaps money is sent. It is a kind of reciprocal exchange which was how we all traded historically,before money. In old times, trade was about ecological adaptation and about strengthening ties between communities, gifts and bartering ruled. That was before "profit", "self-interest" and the "invisible hand" came into play. Why are we so blinded?